4/22/23

Suspects—Nine (1939) by E.R. Punshon

Last month, I compiled a little best-of list, "The Hit List: Top 10 Favorite Reprints from Dean Street Press," which shined a spotlight on, in my opinion, the best Dean Street Press reprints discussed on this blog and, what has been discussed, comprises only a small fraction of their total output – having reprinted hundreds of vintage mysteries over the past decade. So they went over and above to fill that gawping hole the Rue Morgue Press left behind, but the flood of reprints and additional translations has made it difficult to keep track of everything. I decided to take a break from Christopher Bush and Brian Flynn to return to the first majora Golden Age mystery writer to be resurrected by Dean Street Press, "kindly Mr. Punshon."

E.R. Punshon's Suspects—Nine (1939) is his twelfth detective novel starring Bobby Owen who during this period, in this series, holds the rank of detective-sergeant and "wistfully looking for promotion." Similar to Bush's Ludovic Travers, Punshon allowed Bobby Owen to evolve over time from a young constable (Information Received, 1933) to a Commander of Scotland Yard (Six Were Present, 1956). Just like Flynn, Punshon tried his hands at different styles of detective fiction from magical criminal fantasies (Diabolic Candelabra, 1942) to more sordid, down to earth crimes (The Conqueror Inn, 1943). Suspects—Nine brings a bit of both to the table as Owen is now engaged to the proprietress of "Olive, Hats," Olive Farrar, who Punshon introduced as a love interest in Dictator's Way (1938). Giving a series detective-character a love interest was somewhat of a revolutionary idea when Dorothy L. Sayers made Lord Peter Wimsey fall in love with Harriet Vane in Strong Poison (1930) and married them in Busman's Honeymoon (1937). Margery Allingham (Sweet Danger, 1933) and Ngaio Marsh (Artists in Crime, 1938) followed suit.

So marrying off your inveterate bachelor detective is commonly associated with the Queens of Crime and Punshon seems to have written Suspects—Nine as an homage to their witty, character-driven "manners mystery" – full of social and political satire. The kind of sophisticated, well characterized mystery novel Moray Dalton could have written. 

Suspects-Nine sees Bobby Owen comically getting dragged into a petty case of a misappropriated hat when Olive Farrar's chic West End shop is caught in the middle of a feud in London's high society. Lady Alice Belchamber, "formidable and well-known explorer and traveller," who had "bullied and browbeaten her way through the most remote districts of the darkest continents." There were stories of Lady Alice that "she once had cowed with her riding whip a tribe of armed and furious reputed cannibals," while in her flat hung "a formidable knife with which she admitted having slain the Arab, who, armed with it, had penetrated her tent somewhere in the wilds of the near East." Lady Alice hates Flora Tamar who "enjoyed the deserved reputation of being one of the most beautiful women in London." Flora Tamar is married to Michael Tamar, chairman and managing director of the important Internal Combustion Engine Co., but nonetheless is known to sink her hooks in every pair of trousers that comes near her. They saw Flora Tamar pinched Lady Alice's best boy years ago and the "vindictive old bean" has never forgiven her.

The problem begins when Lady Alice learns "Olive, Hats" had designed and created a hat for Flora Tamar to wear at the forthcoming Royal garden party at Buckingham Palace. Lady Alice convinced the sales woman, Vicky, to show her the hat, tried it on and liked it ("...I said it wasn't for sale, and she shouted that every hat in a hat shop was for sale..."). She simply walked out and mailed them a cheque for £26 5s ("Consolidating the position, that's called"). Olive fully expects to lose Flora as a client and Bobby offers to act as a mediator, but Lady Alice naturally refuses and Flora expects a free new hat. Bobby came away from both meetings with an easy feeling of impending catastrophe and dark, unknown forces moving behind the petty incident of the misappropriated hat.

Bobby had been told Lady Alice somehow seems to keep tabs on Flora Tamar and he learns how when spotting a sleazy private detective, named William Martin, in the entrance hall of Lady Alice's apartment building. Martin has an unsavory, violent reputation who had "narrowly escaped arrest in connection with the case of a woman found strangled and dead in an empty house," but an alibi, though the police believed it false, saved his neck – currently works for one of London's slightly less disreputable private inquiry agencies. Bobby judges Lady Alice to be a formidable enemy and reflects "that Flora Tamar might do well to be upon her guard." But not all is well at the Tamar household as he finds out when accidentally crashing a house party and notices the undercurrent of hostility. But there's more. Michael Tamar takes Bobby aside and confides in him he has received an extortion note, of sorts, saying "there's plotting against you." If he wants to know more, he has to leave a hundred one pound notes in a tin under a stone on Weeton Hill. And that's the place where not long after a body is discovered.

The victim is identified as Munday, butler to Michael and Flora Tamar, who had been shot in the face several times and a knife wound that was inflicted about half an hour after death! A detail that lends "to the murder a strange element of the wholly inexplicable." Bobby has to comb through to the nine titular suspects to find the person who had motive and opportunity to shoot and stab a dead butler on that hillside.

First and obviously, he has to consider Munday's employers, the Tamars and two of Flora's suspected lovers, Holland Kent and Julius "Judy" Patterson. Secondly, Michael Tamar's nephew and heir in lieu of children, Roger Renfield. Thirdly, the vengeful Lady Alice along with her potentially dangerous private investigator and her lovely niece, Ernestine “Ernie” Maddox. She has been involved with Judy who lives by his wits ("cards and all that") and a regular the Cut and Come Again. A London nightclub that has figured in more than one Bobby Owen novel. Finally, there's the possibility of an unknown person, or simply "X," which would bring the whole investigation back where it begun. Bobby tackles the problem through good, solid police work ("it's just plodding, sir") and the so-called "mainly conversation" approach with one of the chapters even being titled "More Conversation," but complexity of the plot and detailed characterization never makes it a drag to read. And the many intricacies and possibilities never muddy or clutter the story.

In that regard, Suspects—Nine is a reminder of what I initially admired so much about Punshon's detective fiction. A skill to erect and navigate complicated, maze-like plots and manipulate, intertwined plot-strands like a master puppeteer. Suspects—Nine is a good example how effortlessly Punshon moved around a plot with many different moving parts and large, clearly defined cast of characters running mostly on emotions without getting all tangled up in a mess. Only thing you can really say against Suspects—Nine is that Punshon has done it even better in other novels (There's a Reason for Everything, 1945), but nothing that should take away from this excellent, Golden Age mystery.

I disagree with Nick Fuller's review in which he states that "the means Bobby Owen uses to reach that solution – police routine rather than psychological introspection – is disappointing in a book with so many detailed characters and tortuous emotions." Bobby Owen notes towards the end that, somehow, the murder of the apparently inconspicuous, unimportant Munday sprang from this "welter of passion, intrigue and claim, of counter claim and counter passion, intrigue and counter intrigue." A lot of what happens in this story is driven by all kinds of emotions, seldom rationally, which is why the murder appeared to be so incomprehensible. So figuring out the solution with calm, commonsense thinking and good, old-fashioned police routine worked better than as when Bobby had given away his best Hercule Poirot imitation. It felt really satisfying when from Bobby's memorandum (fact list) the truth emerged "so long and so strangely overlooked." A solution revealing Suspects—Nine not only as very well executed, vintage whodunit with a clever take on the general lack of alibis among the suspects, but showing it was also somewhat of masterclass in diverting suspicion. A great, long overdue return to this series and comes highly recommended to everyone who enjoys these sophisticated, character-driven 1930s mystery novels.

4/20/23

Inspector De Klerck and a Fatal Compromise (2023) by P. Dieudonné

I remarked in previous commentaries of the Inspector De Klerck series that P. Dieudonné is the first writer to not only succeed in emulating A.C. Baantjer's format for what has become the oer-Hollandse police procedural, or politieroman (police novel), to perfection, but managed to make it his own – expanding and building on it rather than living off it fumes. This series is no attempt at a cash clone or nostalgia act as has been attempted in the past. Dieudonné is the Adrian Monk to Baantjer's Lt. Columbo. So the series certainly bears a resemblance to its illustrious fore-bearer and hits a nostalgic note, or two, along the way, but, internally, does its own thing. For one, Dieudonné grounded the series in the world of today and another is that his plots have a tendency to tighter, knottier affairs than those found in Baantjer's novels. Not to mention the variety in stories and type of plots, while remaining stylistically uniform. 

Rechercheur De Klerck en moord in scène (Inspector De Klerck and Murder on the Scene, 2021) imported inner city problems from American and turned it into a theatrically-staged whodunit. Rechercheur De Klerck en het duistere web (Inspector De Klerck and the Dark Web, 2022) dives down the rabbit hole of internet conspiracy theories in which one of the victims scrawled a dying message in blood. Rechercheur De Klerck en een dodelijk pact (Inspector De Klerck and a Deadly Pact, 2022) is a bizarre, pulp-style police procedural about wholesale murder and a vanishing chalet. So, naturally, the plot-mechanics of the eighth novel also differs from its predecessors. 

Rechercheur De Klerck en een fataal compromise (Inspector De Klerck and a Fatal Compromise, 2023) begins with a fun bit of banter between Lucien de Klerck and Ruben Klaver on so-called serious critics and reviewers. De Klerck had appeared in a book as "an unnamed Rotterdam detective," but literary critics "found it unbelievable, out of date, that the main character was happily married" and "had no drug addicted kids" or "even a father suffering from dementia who always paints the same chicken" – simply "not acceptable to the gentlemen reviewers." Things get serious when De Klerck and Klaver are called to a community garden, Jouw Paradijs (Your Paradise), where the body of a woman has been found hanging from a tree. The police officer on the spot suspects it might be murder rather than suicide.

The victim is identified as a widow of three years, Sandra Stobbelaer-van Belzen, who has been living with her brother-in-law at his farm since her husband passed away and made a bit of a mess of her personal life.

Sandra had an illicit affair with a married woman, Mireille van Houten, whose wife, Regina van Houten, "tolerates no rival." But her family relations were also severely disrupted over an inheritance. Sandra's brother, Pieter, was not pleased when discovering that the inheritance from their Uncle Gerardus was substantially less than expected and accused his sister of draining their uncle's bank account ("...always managed to wind Uncle Gerardus around her cunning little finger"). She got the same complaint from her cousin, Arnoud de Rouwe. Sandra and Pieter's older brother, Henk, tells De Klerck how he wondered if there was something more to the death of their uncle. And perhaps Pieter was ticked-off about something more serious than a meager inheritance. There are other factors complicating De Klerck and Klaver's investigation. The secretary of the community garden, Bart Muurling, who discovered the body is incapable of telling a straight, truthful story. A gold ring that had been a heirloom since the family still lived in the Dutch East Indies and another bone of contention among the heirs of Uncle Gerardus. Why did a dead tourist carry a newspaper clipping with the obituary of Uncle Gerardus?

So, despite its modern exterior and up-to-date characters, the plot on which Inspector De Klerck and a Fatal Compromise runs is that of 1930s whodunit with its unbreakable alibis, heritage hazards, a dysfunctional family and a missing heirloom – ending with a gathering and confrontation of all the suspects. Dieudonné and De Klerck attempted, admirably so, to go for a rug-puller of ending, but only partially succeeded.

The revelation of the murderer itself certainly had an element of surprise about it, when it was sprung on the reader, but its effect got somewhat bogged down in the complicated misdirection. And the explanation threw some extra, impossible to anticipate weight behind something important regarding the motive, which I thought was a trifle weak and an unconvincing motive to snuff out several people. Nevertheless, while the ending, particularly the motive, could have been improved upon, Inspector De Klerck and a Fatal Compromise holds up the overall quality of the series and still leagues ahead of the average Dutch politieroman. That's not damning with faint praise. Your average, Dutch politieroman seldom has anything more than a very basic plots that lean heavily on the series-character and location to carry the day. Playing around with concepts like clueing, misdirection, alibi-breaking, dying messages and impossible crimes was practically unheard of until E-Pulp arrived on the scene. Perhaps that's why nobody who tried to step into Baantjer's shoes enjoyed his longevity. Dieudonné and De Klerck have so much more to offer than a warm, humanistic homicide cop and book covers with city scenes. That being said, I very much enjoyed the little subplot playing out in the background of the story showing that something different can be done with the tried-and-tested.

So you place all of the blame for still not having revisited the work of Baantjer solely on this series, because it has been doing an excellent job in satiating those nostalgic cravings. I eagerly look forward to Rechercheur De Klerck en de ongewenste dood (Inspector De Klerck and the Unwanted Death, 2023). 

A note for the curious: I shoved this review in between scheduled posts, because didn't want to reschedule any of the planned posts, but came at the cost of yesterday's review of Brian Flynn's Reverse the Charges (1943). So if you missed it, you can find it here.

4/19/23

Reverse the Charges (1943) by Brian Flynn

Brian Flynn's Reverse the Charges (1943) is the twenty-ninth novel featuring his consulting detective, Anthony Bathurst, which brings him to the village and Chief-Inspector Andrew MacMorran, of Scotland Yard, to the village of Mallett and the surrounding district – where an active serial killer is on the prowl. The case begins on a wet, windy March evening when Constable Wragg heard "a far-away scream" tearing through the night. And he found something downright bizarre.

A car standing on the road, "no obvious sign of collision or accident," whose dying driver lay slumped over the steering wheel with "a look of convulsed, contorted horror." Constable Wragg smells "something burning" inside the car without anything appearing to be on fire. Dr. Pegram, Divisional Surgeon, examines the body and finds six small glowing cinders lodged between his vest and the small of his back. Someone had dumped a small scoop of red-hot cinders down the victim's back and "the shock must have killed him." Sir Charles Stuart, Chief Constable, does not want to call in the Yard as it would be tantamount to an early confessions of failure. So the local police, represented by Inspector Venables, gets a first crack at the case.

The victim is identified as William Norman, farmer, who went to the market in Mallett and stayed, as customary, the whole day and had his dinner at the White Lion inn. Norman then drove home, picked someone up along the way and got murdered in a very outlandish way. Dr. Pegram discusses the case with the village physician, Dr. Martin Chavasse, who believes they have a homicidal maniac on their hands and fears a second murder before too long, because "a murderer of that type never stops at one" – which turned out to be "regrettably accurate." The body of Henry King, a baker, was found sitting at the dining table in the saloon of the White Lion. King had dropped in for lunch and is served with a dish of poisoned fish. A day later, Sir Charles calls in Scotland Yard and MacMorran is dispatched to Mallett together with Bathurst. Three days later, the drowned body of the third victim is found stuffed inside a water barrel standing in the courtyard of the White Lion.

So the murderer appears to be escalating, but, after the third murder, there's a sudden lull in the killings. It appeared as if the case was going to be "the first in the whole of Anthony Lotherington Bathurst's career as a criminologist which he was forced to relinquish." No new developments or a tantalizing clue came to him during the time spent in Mallett. Bathurst had to abandon and possibly write off the case as a failure, but was called back to Mallett when the body of an 11-year-old child is found in the smoking room of the White Lion.

Admittedly, Reverse the Charges has a premise as fascinating as it's puzzling. Flynn leaves some doubt whether you're reading a vintage serial killer mystery in the same vein as Philip MacDonald's Murder Gone Mad (1931) or something more cerebral like Agatha Christie's Murder is Easy (1939). Either way, the first-half had all the ingredients to make Reverse the Charges a standout of its kind, but the pace slackened during the second-half and Flynn really stretched out the ending. Not necessarily a bad thing or enough to sink a story, but it has to deliver something worthwhile in the end. That really didn't happen here.

First of all, the murderer enjoyed an incredible run of luck and particularly that first murder was nothing less than a gamble, which, once again, is acceptable enough as a short-lived run of luck is a defining trait of the fictitious murderer – only the method was completely glossed over. Dumping a handful of red-hot cinders down somebody's back on a cold, rainy evening is not as easy as it sounds. You can't simply say the murderer simply emptied a container of them down Norman's collar when he bent forward ("owing to the weather") to peer through the driving-screen. How where the cinders kept hot enough to cause fatal injuries? And him dying was not certainty at all ("his heart wasn't as strong, perhaps, as it might have been... but otherwise he was all right as far as I know"). If Norman had not died of shock and was only severely burned, the murderer's plan would have collapsed there and then as Norman would simply tell Constable Wragg who attacked him. So nothing really clever or inspired to it all, which is not helped when a very familiar-looking and expected solution emerges towards the end. One that has been done before and much better. Thirdly, there's an odd, stylistic choice in storytelling as the second-half introduces the plot-thread of Dr. Chavasse's mysterious, dying patient who had bouts of recovery during which he ventured outside. That plot-thread should have been expanded upon and the mysterious episodes with him peppered throughout the story. It would have livened up the pace of the second-half tremendously as the murders could be spread out a little more and shorten the dragging towards the end. It genuinely would have been an overall improvement to both the plot and storytelling.

So, as some of you armchair detectives have probably deduced by now, Reverse the Charges can not be counted among the best and finest detective novel Flynn crafted during his decades long career, but enjoyable enough to recommend to established fans of the series.

4/15/23

The Night of the 12th-13th (1931) by S.A. Steeman

Stanislas-André Steeman was a French-speaking Belgian illustrator, journalist and mystery novelist whom Xavier Lechard lionized as "one of the greatest mystery writers of all times." Steeman was an important, seminal figure of the early French Golden Age detective story whose work is "very representative" of French detective fiction of the 1930s that emphasizes originality, inventiveness and occasionally subverting the rules – while upholding the tenants of "rigour, fair play and cleverness" of his Anglo-Saxon counterparts. Only two of his celebrated novels were translated into English in the thirties and have never been reprinted since their original publication. So secondhand copies of the English translations tend to be as scarce as they're expensive with a copy of Six hommes morts (Six Dead Men, 1930/31) recently going on sale for $1250 plus shipping. Not all of his work is hopelessly out of reach.

Fortunately, the French-speaking Steeman had sense enough to be Belgian and therefore practically all of his mystery novels have appeared in Dutch/Flemish translations. Most of them published during the 1930s and '40s. And while copies turn up about as often as the English translations, the Dutch/Flemish editions seem to be much more reasonably priced, if they turn up. So immediately pounced on the Dutch/Flemish translations of Steeman's La nuit du 12 au 13 (The Night of the 12th-13th, 1931) when one finally headed my direction. I'd say it was influential on the French detective story of the thirties, like those published by John Pugmire's Locked Room International, but more on that in a moment. 

The Night of the 12th-13th is the second title in the Wenceslas "Wens" Vorobeitchik series and begins with setting up two separate, but obviously intertwined, plot-threads concerning a husband and wife.

Floriane Aboody is on her way to Confucius, "a shop of Chinese and Japanese goods and antiques," where she has an appointment with Van Hou Yen, but a shop assistant, Jean Heldinge, tells her he's currently absent – as is his partner, Ling Chu. However, the latter appears a few moments later to inform Floriane that Van Hou Yen will visit her home that evening. Which he does. The secretive meeting ends with Van Hou Yen handing a small parcel tied with a golden cord over to Floriane. Meanwhile, her husband, Herbert Aboody, has troubles of his own. Herbert Aboody is a co-director of an import-and export company, H. Aboody, J.B. Lawrence & Co, who has been receiving threatening letters over the past few weeks. The most recent letter informing the co-direction, "if you persevere and leave matters as they are, you will die on the night of the 12th and the 13th." Aboody's secretary, Stève Alcan, recommends him to consult a detective. This brings Wenceslas Vorobeitchik into the investigation who's not impressed with the case ("can you find something more banal than threatening letters") and critically underestimated the severity of the case. And not without consequences!

Wens proposes to spent the night of the 12th and the 13th together with Aboody in his (locked) office at the import-and export company, which he considers to be a secure location with a police detective patrolling the grounds outside. But what he fears mostly is that "this night will pass terribly calmly." Famous last words as the police detective outside hears the unmistakable sound of gunshots. Aboody was dead with a bullet in his head, while Wens had been critically injured as he was struck in the chest and leg with his body blocking the already locked office door. So that effectively takes Wens out of the case and story, which leaves the case in the hands of three other detectives. Namely the juge d'instruction, or examining magistrate, M. Plante, Inspector Aimé Malaise and Inspector Walter. Xavier Lechard did say Steeman both deeply respected the rule while "never afraid to subvert them" or "gently poking fun at them." The Night of the 12th-13th is a good example as it did not play out as an ordinary, 1930s detective novel!

There's an odd little thing about the locked room situation and I don't know if it was edited out of the translation or done on purpose, but the shooting of Aboody and Wens is never once acknowledged, treated or discussed as an impossible crime – which unnecessarily detracts from a cleverly-constructed and plotted (locked room) mystery. If it was done on purpose, it perhaps betrayed on undeserved lack of confidence in the strength of the plot and fearing to give away too much, too soon. If the translation is a condensed version, I feel slightly cheated out of my locked room fix.

Either way, you can clearly see Steeman's influence on other traditionally-minded French mystery writers of the period from even a possibly abridged translation of The Night of the 12th-13th. Noël Vindry, in particular, appears to have modeled his novels somewhat on Steeman and The Night of the 12th-13th. Vindry's series-detective is shot and wounded under impossible circumstances in La maison qui tu (The House That Kills, 1932) and the double shooting recalls the locked room problem from Le bête hurlante (The Howling Beast, 1934), while the case-for-three-detectives approach resembles Michel Herbert and Eugène Wyl's La maison interdite (The Forbidden House, 1932). The distinctly, pulp-style trappings of the plot also begs a comparison with Alexis Gensoul and Charles Grenier's La mort vient de nulle part (Death Out of Nowhere, 1945) and Marcel Lanteaume's La 13e balle (The Thirteenth Bullet, 1948), but The Night of the 12th-13th comes with a thick dollop of yellow peril. You can probably place some blame on that element for the drought in reprints over the decades.

But, purely on its merits as a detective story, it definitely deserves to be reprinted as it more than delivered on its premise. And what looked like a routine investigation following the spectacular shooting inside the locked office. An investigation in which the increasingly frustrated detectives become entangled in a web of romantic relationships, embezzlement, faked alibis, missing suspects, sinister Chinese and a noticeably growing conspiracy of silence surrounding the mysterious events on the night of the 12th and the 13th. Steeman pulls everything tightly together in the last chapters with a satisfying and for the time original explanation to the whole perplexing case. I anticipated the correct solution, but not because of any of my own cleverness or delusions of being on par as an armchair detective with Mycroft Holmes. The solution has, thematically, something in common with a few other (locked room) mystery novels from this period (SPOILER/ROT13: Jnygre F. Znfgrezna'f Gur Jebat Yrggre naq Nyna Gubznf' Gur Qrngu bs Ynherapr Ivavat juvpu nyy unir cybgf fhoiregvat gur ebyrf bs gur qrgrpgvir va n qrgrpgvir fgbel qverpgyl yvaxrq gb gur ybpxrq ebbz-gevpx).

So it didn't take me too long to notice the pattern and it gave me a pretty good idea what really happened in the apparently unconnected prologue, but you can hardly hold that against an otherwise good, solid and at the time innovative detective story. I would like to read a fresh translation to see if anything was cut out of this Dutch/Flemish edition and think a LRI reprint would complement their other French Golden Age translations. But due to the locked room angle going unacknowledged, it might make more sense to reprint The Night of the 12th-13th together with Six Dead Men as a twofer volume. Just a completely unbiased, impartial recommendation from an independent and trustworthy party. :D

4/11/23

Suddenly at His Residence (1946) by Christianna Brand

The past ten years have been a deluge of reprints, translations and even some newer, classically-styled works that turned into a flood of Noah-like proportions ushering in the current period of rediscovery – a renaissance age I predicted in the late 2000s and again towards the end of 2014. Coincidentally, or exactly according to my prediction, the reprint renaissance really began to gain momentum in 2015 as more publishers and imprints appeared. The downside to this success that it's hard sometimes to keep pace with all the new releases. So, usually, I'm trailing behind the new reprints and releases, except this time.

Two months from now, the British Library Crime Classics is going to publish a reprint of Christianna Brand's third novel, Suddenly at His Residence (1946), which was published in the US as The Crooked Wreath and serialized in The Chicago Tribune under the title One of the Family. Suddenly at His Residence has been on the to-be-reread list for a while now. And not without a reason.

I wrote in my reviews of Agatha Christie's Murder on the Orient Express (1934) and John Dickson Carr's The Three Coffins (1935) that the current reprint renaissance coincided with some very famous, time-honored classics having their status reevaluated and sometimes downgraded – which also went the other way round. For example, Carr's Till Death Do Us Part (1944) once had the profile of a decent, mid-tier title from the Dr. Gideon Fell series, but today, it's looked upon as one of Carr's finest detective novels. During the 2000s, Brand's Suddenly at His Residence tended to be dismissed as an inferior, mid-tier work dragged down by melodramatic sentimentality and not anywhere near the same league as Green for Danger (1944), Death of Jezebel (1948) and London Particular (1952). But that began to chance towards the end of the decade. Just compare Nick Fuller's 2001 and John Norris' 2011 reviews. Nowadays, Suddenly at His Residence is highly regarded and some even consider the book to be among the best impossible crime novels the genre has produced.

I've only read Suddenly at His Residence in a Dutch translation, ages ago, remember very little beside the spectacular, unforgettable ending and those final lines. So why not take a second look in anticipation of the British Library reprint to see if its recent status upgrade is justified.

Once upon a time, Sir Richard March was married to a ballerina, Serafita, who gave him three sons, but he also kept a mistress, Bella, with an illegitimate child in a bijou house at Yarmouth. Somewhat of an open secret. Serafita predicted she would die young and Sir Richard would bring Bella to the house where she would "listen to nothing but 'Serafita,' 'Serafita,' 'Serafita,' till she is sick of the very sound of my name," which is exactly what happened. Sir Richard turned Swanswater into a shrine to his first wife full of "ancestor worship and ballet-dancing and rose-wreaths and coloured gloves." But the family has changed since the days of Serafita. The three sons had been killed in the First World War, their wives were gone and only the grandchildren were left. You can say they form the typical, dysfunctional family that tend to inhabit these type of country house mysteries.

Philip Marsh, "returned from that heathen America where in his childhood his mother had taken him," to settle down into a promising medical practice with a wife, Ellen, and a newborn child. Only they have quickly grown apart as Philip began an affair with his cousin, Claire, who "insisted upon working in some dreadful newspaper office" and raised her grandfather's ire with her ideas about "independence and a career." Peta is the darling of Sir Richard and heir to his fortune, which the family lawyer, Stephen Garde, had fought for and won – "and in so doing, himself had lost." A quiet country lawyer does not secure "a hearty fortune" for a young lady and then ask her to marry him. Edward Treviss is their half-cousin and the only grandson of Sir Richard and Bella. Edward had lost his parents in a boating accident, which everyone assumed he had witnessed and discovered as a child he could exploit his assumed trauma ("the next time he was due for a spanking, therefore, he had put his little hand to his forehead and declared that it felt queer"). Something he continues to do as an 18-year-old to get attention and have people "express anxiety about him."

They are all coming down to Swanswater, two miles out of the small town of Heronsford, in Kent, to take part in the ceremony that Sir Richard always held on the anniversary of Serafita's death. It goes without saying they test their grandfather's patience and ends with him banging the table, "I'll cut you all out of my will, the whole ungrateful pack of you," instructs Stephen to draft a new will. Sir Richard also announces his intention, despite being in poor health, to spent the night alone in the lodge where Serafita had died. What you expect to happen is discovered next morning.

Apparently, Sir Richard died from over stimulation of his "dickey heart," but Philip concludes somebody killed him when he notices that Sir Richard's medication and a phial of strychnine missing from his bag. But how could someone have been possibly poisoned him? There were three, narrow paths running up through the rose beds to the lodge, "one to the back door, and one to the French window of the sitting-room," which were freshly sanded and smoothed over shortly after Sir Richard retreated into the lodge – two of the paths were innocent of footprints. The third path only showed Clair's footprints as she walked up the path with a breakfast tray and spotted Sir Richard's body sitting at his desk through the French window. Nobody could possibly have pushed a way through the roses without bringing "down a shower of petals." The doors and windows were all closed and locked. A pretty little puzzle!

Inspector Cockrill, "a dusty little old sparrow arrayed in a startlingly clean white panama hat," makes his third appearance, but largely acts as a spectator as he rolls cigarettes, observes and occasionally stirring the pot to keep everyone talking (“he liked to get his suspects talking”). So the focus remains firmly on the family and with a very good reason. Suddenly at His Residence pretty much plays out like one, very big and long family row during which various members accuse each other of murder complete with a false-solution to explain how they could have done it. Some of these false-solutions are not without ingenuity and form an impressive whole considering how many different possibilities Brand came up that needed to fit as many different characters as well as the unchanging facts of the murder. Outsiders also get in on the fun. A personal favorite comes during the inquest when one of the jurors proposes a false-solution, which barely holds up on a second glance, but his fellow jurors liked it so much, they brought in a verdict of murder against one of the family members. And that forced an arrest.

Fortunately, the body of the gruff, unlikable gardener, Brough, is found not long thereafter in the sitting room of the lodge with a poisonous needle in his arm. On the dusty tiles in the hallway, near his right hand, was written "I KILLED SIR R." Everything was "locked and sealed from the inside" and "there was no possible way of getting there except across the hall,” but “there were simply acres of untrodden dust between him and the door." So when evidence is found that pulls the rug from under the suicide theory, Cockrill suddenly has two impossible crimes on his hands and a family of whom one is now twice a murderer.

The strength of Suddenly at His Residence is not in the pair of no-footprints puzzles. Judging the book solely on the impossible crimes, the tricks are good enough with the second, dusty murder finding a clever new way to do that trick, but, by themselves, would hardly justify a classical status. Nor is the strength in the clues and red herrings or the who-and why. But the pure craftsmanship of the plot construction. And the pure showmanship in telling an otherwise fairly cliched country house mystery. What sets the well intended amateur apart from the masters is how much they'll allow the reader to know. An amateur closely guards clues and important information in fear of giving away too much, too early, while a master simply shows them or parades them around in front of the reader – hoping you either missed or misinterpreted those clues. What separates the masters from true legends like Brand, Carr and Christie is an unrivaled ability to rub the truth in your face or casually refer to an important clue and simultaneously pull the wool over your eyes. A talent that made lesser-known Carr and Christie novels, like Death in the Clouds (1935), The Crooked Hinge (1938), The Problem of the Green Capsule (1939) and Evil Under the Sun (1941), tower above the best works of their contemporaries. Brand had that talent as well and she went all in with it here. 

Suddenly at His Residence is already fairly clued to the point where you can call it immaculate with (HUGE SPOILER/ROT13) gur pevzr fprar orvat n fuevar gb n qrnq onyyrevan, ohg Oenaq gbbx vg n srj fgrcf shegure ol qrcvpgvat Pynver fgnaqvat “irel fgenvtug naq ybiryl” orarngu gur cbegenvg bs Frensvgn cbfvat ba cvax gbr-cbvagf nf fur snprq Pbpxevyy. Be abapunynagyl ersrerapvat gur inphhz pyrnare fgnaqvat va gur unyyjnl zbzragf nsgre gur frpbaq ivpgvz vf sbhaq. This kind of brazen confidence and command of the plot elevated everything from the impossible murders to the multiple, false-solutions to the solution and bombshell ending. An amazing, completely fair and acceptable dues ex machina plot-device to help resolve everything that happened at Swanswater and none of it would have landed without the sound structure erected underneath it all. A lesser writer and plotted would not have been able pull it off and raise an essentially thoroughly cliched detective story to something that can stand with the best from the best.

Only thing Suddenly at His Residence has going against itself is Brand wrote much better, superior detective novels and suspect its once poor reputation came from comparisons to London Particular. A painfully human detective story in which a tightly-knit, caring family construct false-solution to implicate themselves in order to protect the others. When you compare that to the family row here with relatives accusing each other of murder, even an excellently constructed and executed detective story like Suddenly at His Residence can appear cheap and gaudy. I'm sure the premise of a patriarch getting murdered after announcing he's going to change his will didn't do its reputation any favors at the time, which is why its recent reevaluation based solely on its own merits is more than deserved. I only wish I had an eye back then to see and appreciate how skillfully and audaciously everything had been put together, but those very skills is what makes the best detective stories stand up to a second read. Another thing Brand apparently has in common with Carr and Christie. So, cutting another long, rambling review short, Suddenly at His Residence is an excellent Golden Age mystery that comes highly recommended!

On a final, somewhat unrelated note: I got my hands all over a really obscure, long out-of-print, but supposedly very good, locked room mystery in even more obscure, never reprinted Dutch translation. So stay tuned!

4/8/23

The Mill House Murders (1988) by Yukito Ayatsuji

Soji Shimada's Senseijutsu satsujinjiken (The Tokyo Zodiac Murders, 1981) and Naname yashiki no hanzai (Murder in the Crooked House, 1982) cracked the thick ice that covered the post-war detective story in Japan, "the winter of the age of honkaku," handing the next generation of mystery writers a blueprint to carry forward the traditional detective story into the new century – ending the dominance of Seicho Matsumoto's social school. Just not right away. Well, not until Yukito Ayatsuji debuted with Jukkakukan no satsujin (The Decagon House Murders, 1987). A novel seen as the first wave of the shin honkaku (neo-orthodox) movement and remembered in Japan, to quote Shimada, "as an epoch-making event which transformed the world of Japanese mystery fiction with revolutionary new ideas."

Fittingly, John Pugmire's Locked Room International and Ho-Ling Wong's 2015 translation of The Decagon House Murders ushered in a new phase of the reprint renaissance that had been slowly gathering steam during the 2000s and really began to pick up momentum over the next decade.

Locked Room International had been mainly publishing Paul Halter and some odds and ends like a translation of Jean-Paul Török's Carrian pastiche L'enigme du Monte Verita (The Riddle of Monte Verita, 2007) and The Derek Smith Omnibus (2014). The Decagon House Murders appears to have given the traditionally-grounded, non-English mysteries legitimize and opened the floodgates to, what Brian Skupin called, a translation wave – one that's getting progressively bigger every year. Locked Room International continued with translations of writers such as Takemaru Abiko, Alice Arisugawa, Tetsuya Ayukawa, Masahiro Imamura and Pushkin Vertigo followed suit with reprints and new translations of Soji Shimada, Akimitsu Takagi and Seishi Yokomizo. In addition to a smattering of publications from smaller publishers like Yamaguchi Masaya's Ikeru shikabane no shi (Death of the Living Dead, 1989), Hiroko Minagawa's Hirakasete itadaki kōei desu (The Resurrection Fireplace, 2011) and MORI Hiroshi's Seven Stories (2017). And this only touches upon the Japanese mysteries that were ferried across the language barrier since 2015!

More importantly, Yukito Ayatsuji might very well have done exactly what Shimada predicted in his introduction to the LRI edition of The Decagon House Murders. In his introduction, Shimada discussed the shin honkaku movement and stated, "it is my belief that if we can introduce this concept to the field of American and British detective fiction, the Golden Age pendulum will swing back, just as The Tokyo Zodiac Murders and The Decagon House Murders managed to accomplish in Japan." You can argue the translation wave is leaving it traces as can been seen in the recently published A. Carver's The Author is Dead (2022), Jim Noy's The Red Death Murders (2022) and the work of James Scott Byrnside. So it was about time Yukito Ayatsuji got another novel translated into English.

Back in 2020, Pushkin Vertigo acquired the publishing rights of The Decagon House Murders and reprinted the book in a brand new edition. Every reprint of a previously published Japanese author from Pushkin Vertigo eventually receives new translations. It happened to Shimada and Yokomizo and expected it to happen to Ayatsuji some time before it was announced.

Yukito Ayatsuji's Suishakan no satsujin (The Mill House Murders, 1988) is the second entry in the yakata (mansion) series. The strange mansions providing a backdrop for each novel is the creation of Nakamura Seiji, "a curious architect," who "would only work on curious houses, projects that happened to coincide with whatever theme interested him at the time" and "he'd always conceal childish tricks in those houses" – which appear to have began to attract horrific tragedies. Seiji had died in a house he himself had built called the Blue Mansion when it went up in flames. A series of murders took place in another strange house designed by Seiji, the Decagon House. There's always one person who seem to be connected to the mansion tragedies, Shimada Kiyoshi. So begins to travel around Japan "to see what more evil Nakamura Seiji's creations have led to." On his second outing, Shimada travels deep into the mountains north of Okayama Prefecture to visit the Mill House.

The Mill House is a European-style, castle-like building situated in an isolated valley and is named for the three large water wheels attached to the mansion to generate power. A very remote, sparsely populated area, but even there the Mill House got a nickname as some refer to it as Mask Manor. A reference "after its unusual-looking master," Fujinuma Kiichi, who's the son of the late, well-known visionary painter, Fujinuma Issei. Twelve years ago, Kiichi emerged from a car wreck with severely damaged limbs and a horrendously disfigured face. Now wears a white rubber mask to hide his "accursed features" and had the Mill House built to hide from the world. When he had settled into the Mill House, Kiichi began to buy back and hoard all of his father's paintings ("the art world had dubbed it the Fujinuma Collection"). The Mill House has guests only once a year, on 28th September, the day Fujinuma Issei passed away when only four men are allowed to view the collection. Ōishi Genzō, Mori Shigehiko, Mitamura Noriyuki and Furukawa Tsunehito. All four connected to the Fujinumas and the reason why they're allowed to view the collection once a year.

A year ago, the traditional viewing of the Fujinuma Collection became the scene of gruesome murder and the downright impossible. Firstly, the housekeeper, Negishi Fumie, fell to her death from the tower and her body was seen being carried away by the rushing water. Secondly, a painting disappeared from the wall of the Northern Gallery and Furukawa Tsunehito is assumed to have taken it. Thirdly, Furukawa impossibly disappeared from the first floor of the locked and watched annex. Lastly, Masaki Shingo, friend of Kiichi and one-time disciple of his father, is killed, cut up in pieces and burnt in the basement incinerator. The police is unable to find a satisfactory explanation outside of blaming the vanished man. So the case, more or less, remains unsolved.

There ends the prologue and becomes a bit tricky discuss as The Mill House Murders is one of the clearest examples of simplistic complexity I've ever come across! The prologue gives the reader a rough idea what happened a year ago and the narrative than switches back and forth between the past and present. The 1985 chapters is a detailed retelling what happened a year ago, while the 1986 chapters sees the surviving members of that tragic night returning to the secluded house, but this time there's an uninvited guest, Shimada Kiyoshi – who's a friend of the man who impossibly disappeared, Furukawa. Shimada asks Kiichi permission to stay and join the yearly gathering to have a look around the place. So the story alternates between chapters set in 1985 that go over the events of the previous year and chapters set a year later detailing Shimada's investigation. When a 1985 chapters shows one of the incidents, you get Shimada going over that part of the house or talking to the people who witnessed something. Shimada asks a question and the next chapters shows the incident he asked about. These alternating past/present chapters, especially the earlier ones, often mirror each other and gives a pleasing symmetric structure to the storytelling and plot. Brilliantly exploited to frame an ultimately simple, absolutely solvable detective story as a warped maze. I referred to this style of plotting as a simplistic complexity and the difficult thing about spinning a great deal of complexity out of an uncomplicated plot is to do it while playing fair and not obfuscate the plot with clutter. Ayatsuji succeeded admirably as there are no irrelevant, extraneous plot-threads needlessly complicating things with everything that has happened, and continues to unfold, at Mill House is relevant to Shimada's solution.

I was actually somewhat surprised how close some of my initial impressions and suspicions were to be to Shimada's solution. While never fully giving up on those first impressions and suspicions, I questioned and doubted all of them with every twist and turn along the way. Not until Shimada finally got an opportunity to take a look at the first floor annex and bedroom from which his friend inexplicably vanished that some of those suspicions began to look not so far fetched after all. The locked room mystery really is my wheelhouse. Even then, I failed to dot all the i's and cross all the t's. I particular liked what lay behind the secret of the locked study.

Well, I can go on rambling about the book, but you probably get the idea by now. I really enjoyed The Mill House Murders. A superbly written, intricately-plotted shin honkaku mystery weaving a seemingly complex patterns out of sheer simplicity. You can see how Soji Shimada and Yukito Ayatsuji's ideas revitalized a genre that had been dominated for decades by social crime novels, which in turn inspired a new generation who completely rejuvenated the traditional detective story. I don't believe the traditional detective story could have found better custodians when it got largely abandoned in the West and eagerly look forward to the translation of Ayatsuji's third yakata novel, Meirokan no satsujin (The Labyrinth House Murders, 1988).

4/4/23

The Cat Saw Murder (1939) by Dolores Hitchens

Dolores Hitchens was an American novelist, who worked as a nurse and teacher before embarking on her writing career, beginning with The Clue in the Clay (1938) and went on to write nearly fifty novels until her death in 1973 – appearing under numerous different (pen) names. Hitchens wrote some hardboiled crime novels and collaborated with her second husband, Hubert A. Hitchens, on a series of railway mysteries. More importantly, she also penned a dozen traditionally-styled detective series in the "Had-I-But-Known" mold under the name "D.B. Olson." A series starring the seventy some Miss Rachel Murdock and her black satin cat, Samantha.

In 2021, American Mystery Classics reprinted the first title in the so-called "Cat" series, The Cat Saw Murder (1939), which comes with an introduction by Joyce Carol Oates. I need to warn readers that the introduction is frustrating at best and infuriating at worst. Like Kate, at Cross Examining Crime, pointed out in her review, Oates "seems so keen to say what these mysteries supposedly lack" and "enjoying such books appear like a guilty or irrational please." Oates also grossly mislabeled The Cat Saw Murder when stating the book "inaugurates what has become a curious publishing phenomenon," the cozy cat mystery. The Cat Saw Murder couldn't be further away from the cozy cat mysteries of today with its cutely illustrated cover and punning titles. It belongs to that darker, gorier corner of the Had-I-But-Known School that include Anita Blackmon's Murder à la Richelieu (1937) and Mabel Seeley's The Listening House (1938). Stories gleefully taking an ax to their characters, slitting their throats, flinging a biting acid in their faces or simply tearing them apart.

So don't expect a nice, sugary cozy about a sweet, grandmotherly maiden aunt and her companion cat solving a nice, clean murder that smells of cinnamon and cyanide. Now that the reader has been warned, let's get to the story. 

The Cat Saw Murder begins (sort of) with Miss Rachel Murdock getting a phone call from her adopted niece, Lily Sticklemann, whom she and her sister, Miss Jennifer Murdock, "had loved wholeheartedly as a child and were faintly ashamed of as a woman." The Misses Murdock view their niece as "obviously and persistently stupid," but it's "an involved stupidity that attempted to simulate cunning," which gave her a penchant for getting into trouble – like getting suckered into a bigamous marriage. Miss Murdock is hardly surprise when Lily asks her to come down to Breakers Beach, because she's in a messy situation and badly needs advise. So she packs a suitcase and putting her cat in a basket to go down to Surf House. A rundown, beachfront boarding house that "looked remarkably ready to fall in upon its tenants." One of the reasons Lily asked her aunt to come down is that a scheme of hers (cheating at cards) backfired spectacularly and now owes a huge sum of money to the Scurlocks. An unpleasant couple who are also staying at Surf House. But it's not the only reason why she's staying at that dump. And, pretty soon, Miss Murdock concludes that not all is right at Surf House. Not soon enough!

Lily is gruesomely murdered with an ax in her bedroom, "that neck wound alone must have spouted like a geyser," while Miss Murdock was sitting next to her heavily drugged with morphine and slipping into a coma ("...a battle for Miss Rachel’s life against morphine and coma and death; and the last had almost got her"). A fascinating and very well done way to introduce an amateur detective to the world of crime, but recovering ties her to the bed for a big chunk of the first-half.

This bloody ax murder brings Lieutenant Stephen Mayhew to the boarding house and should note here that Hitchens introduced Mayhew in The Clue in the Clay, which finds him and his wife, Sara, on honeymoon in San Francisco. However, Mayhew meets Sara at Surf House. So that either makes The Cat Saw Murder a prequel or soft reboot. Mayhew has his doubts whether Miss Murdock can help him, if she survives, because "elderly people were usually slow" and "they neither heard nor saw clearly." But when he finally gets to speak with Miss Murdock, Mayhew got "an inkling of what a really valuable aid this small elderly woman might be" and senses "that keen insight into people and situations that he now thinks was given to Miss Rachel as a special dispensation of the gods." And the moment Miss Murdock enters the game, The Cat Saw Murder returns to the domestic suspense with some Gothic overtones befitting a Had-I-But-Known mystery. Most notably, Miss Murdock hiding in a dark, cold attic while the supposed murderer ransacks her room below and using that same attic to eavesdrop and enter other apartments. There are also other complications cropping up like a tenant who went missing some time ago and a child discovering a severed hand ("...brought proudly home to his mother what he considered to be an unusually fine fat starfish") on the beach "showing evidence of terrible torture."

So does it all stack up in the end? Well, yes, kind of. The plot holds up as everything appeared to fit together and Hitchens honestly attempted to properly clue, or foreshadow, every part of the story and plot. One, extremely blatant, clue made some of the last-minute discoveries, and revelations, partly forgivable as by then you should have a pretty good idea in which direction to look – which admittedly took some of the punch out of the ending. The problem is that everything from the storytelling to the plotting felt shaky, precarious and disjointed. Like a puzzle that had been laid out correctly without connecting the pieces together. It feels incomplete despite being able to make out the entire picture. That can be partially blamed on the pulp-like thriller elements creeping into the narrative towards the end and the sudden, sometimes jarring shifts from present to past tense. It gave the impression that the story and plot are a disjointed mess when it really is a little unevenly in places that some polishing or perhaps a good editor could have fixed. 

The Cat Saw Murder is not a bad beginning to the series. Just not perfectly executed with the end result leaving me a little dissatisfied, but not disappointed enough to give one of the later titles a pass. Death Walks on Cats Feet (1956) sounds like it could possibly make up for this poorly written, lukewarm review.

3/31/23

It's a Numbers Game: Q.E.D. vol. 23-24 by Motohiro Katou

The first of two stories from Motohiro Katou's Q.E.D. vol. 23, "The Liar," begins with Sou Touma arriving in Taiwan to meet his parents and sister, Yuu, who secretly invited his friend, Kana Mizuhara, to come along – because their parents "wanted to meet the girl who's close to Sou." Kana really wanted to meet Sou's mysterious, somewhat eccentric parents. Only problem is that they're not at the airport to meet Sou and Yuu. When they call their parents, Yuu is told they traveled to Okinawa and want them to go there as well. But there are no planes going to Okinawa for another day or two. And every ship has been booked full.

Fortunately, they bump into Ryan Garrett, director of an IT firm, who was at MIT together with Sou and planned on going to Okinawa himself. So he offers them a ride on his luxury cruiser. Sou is not too thrilled to accept the favor as Ryan Garrett was known as "Ryan the Liar" at MIT ("...the type who sweet talks to achieve his goal") and there's always a catch to being indebted to him.

When they board the luxury cruiser, Sou, Yuu and Kana find that they're not the only passengers. Ryan invited along a handful of people. John Harris, a business partner of sorts, whose runs an IT company that's a subdivision of Ryan's firm. Al and Martha Moss are teachers from Arizona whose son was a classmate of Ryan. Lastly, there is Ryan's alcoholic ex-girlfriend, Beth Bloom, who still holds a grudge and her current boyfriend, Barry Force. Something is obviously brooding as Ryan promises Sou "there is a surprising result waiting for us tomorrow," but what awaits him the next morning is Ryan's body bathing "in a sea of blood." Sou uncovers that all five suspects possess both motives strong enough to kill and alibis accounting for their movement on the night of the murder. Sou posits that "among the five of them, there is a liar, and that lie was what brought about this whole situation," which is an incredibly good and clever solution – a twisted inversion of a very well-known detective novel. Just as impressive is Sou's Ellery Queen-like chain of deductions and reasoning demonstrating why none of the other suspects could have done it ("thus, ends my demonstration"). A detective story in the purest sense of the word and the most conventional one from these two volumes.

The next story, "Another World,' brings Sou and Kana to New Jersey. Two years previously, a mathematician working on proving the Riemann Hypothesis, Professor Kenneth Refla, invited to Sou to return in two years to witnessing him unveiling the solution. And making history in the process. Those two years have come and gone, Sou returned to New Jersey to witness this great event. Sou tries to explain explain this "famous conjecture which no one has been able to prove for 150 years" to Kana ("Ha, I didn't under a single word"), but it boils down to "if the Riemann Hypothesis can be proven, a connection between the real and abstract world of prime numbers can be established." But, when they arrive, they're told that the presentation has been canceled months ago. Professor Kenneth Refla has simply disappeared from the face of Earth. So what happened? But left behind a number of clues.

Firstly, a quatrain, a poem with four lines, is found stuck to the window of his home office. Secondly, he distributed four paintings depicting lines from the quatrain. Thirdly, a coded tombstone. However, "Another World" is not, strictly speaking, a traditional mystery, but one of those really strange, character-driven and surprisingly humanistic mathematical puzzles you can only find in this series – reminiscent of "The Frozen Hammer" (vol. 9) and "Dedekind Cut" (vol. 15). Just not nearly as effective or poignant as previous attempts at such stories. Although I liked that brief moment towards the end between Sou and Kana ("don't worry, I won't go over to that side"). So a nice little bit of storytelling, but, on a whole, not the best or most memorable entry in the series.

I really should have planned out these reviews, because vol. 24 opens with a seasonal-themed mystery, "Christmas Eve Eve," which is appropriately a very minor mystery with an even slighter plot. Sou and Kana take a part-time job together at a karaoke bar to earn some extra pocket money to buy presents. What they end up doing is playing Santa's Little Helpers by clearing up some minor crimes and misunderstandings among the other employees of the karaoke bar ranging from a possibly stolen wallet to a potentially cheating boyfriend. A nicely-done, but really threadbare, detective story that I've nothing to say about at the moment. I might return to it in December and review it separately as it probably works slightly better when you're in the Christmas spirit. Only time will tell.

The second and last story, "Crime and Punishment," is a quasi-inverted mystery with a ultimately simplistic, but delicious, twist ending.

Kunihiko Sendagawa, a post-grad student, is struggling to make ends meet and "a mountain of debt bills" on his doormat keeps growing. That eats at his mind. After all, why does someone as smart as him needs to struggle for money? But he gets an idea when he learns a serial burglar is active in neighborhood. So he decides to start burglarizing houses beginning with his own place in order to divert suspicion ("the police wouldn't suspect a previous victim like me"), but, on his second job, Sendagawa finds the body of an elderly man – brutally beaten to death with a golf club. Unfortunately, for him, the policeman on the case is Kana Mizuhara's father and Inspector Mizuhara is no Lestrade. While he initially thinks "the serial burglary case has finally escalated to burglary and murder," Inspector Mizuhara begins to notice inconsistencies in Sendagawa's statements and takes note of his outright suspicious behavior. So decides to start playing Columbo with the post-grad student ("it's so annoying to be followed like that"). Sendagawa turns in desperation to Sou and Kana to help him out of his current predicament, but Sou tells him Inspector Mizuhara wouldn't suspect a person without a reason and advises him to simply confess whatever he has one his conscience.

Sendagawa naturally ignores Sou's advise and digs an even deeper hole for himself, which eventually brings him back into the case to go over "the distorted hints" that explain who killed the old man and stole the money. I should have seen it coming, but, somehow, completely missed and wanted to kick myself for not immediately figuring out a very basic, tell-all clue (SPOILER/ROT13: “V qvqa'g xvyy gung Fnagn Pynhf-yvxr byq zna!”). A low-key great story and fun to see Inspector Mizuhara getting to enjoy the spotlight for a few fun scenes!

So, all in all, two very solid, highly enjoyable volumes as vol. 23 opened strongly with a cleverly plotted, simon-pure jigsaw-puzzle detective and vol. 24 ended on a high note with an excellent treatment of the inverted mystery. The two stories sandwiched in between are of middling at best, but nothing to the detriment of the overall quality readers have come to expect from this series. More importantly, they demonstrate why Q.E.D. has become a personal favorite of mine. The series will never beat Case Closed as my favorite manga mystery series, but Q.E.D. will be equally hard to wrench from its second place spot. As always, to be continued!

3/28/23

The Killing of Katie Steelstock (1980) by Michael Gilbert

Back in January, I returned to the work of Michael Gilbert and looked at his first mystery novel, Close Quarters (1947), which introduced his series-detectives, Chief Inspector Hazlerigg and Sergeant Pollock, in a commendable debut full of promise – marred only by a somewhat wobbly ending. Close Quarters is nonetheless a praiseworthy first stab at the detective genre with a skillfully handled plot in which all the suspects have seemingly interlocking alibis. So decided to move a few more of his novels up the big pile. 

The Killing of Katie Steelstock (1980), originally published in the UK as Death of a Favourite Girl, is a standalone and reputedly is one of his finest pieces of detective fiction. A classically-styled and structured detective novel subversively presented as a fairly typical, modern police procedural that "pulled off quite a few gasp inducing twists in the final chapters." While I've been aware of The Killing of Katie Steelstock ever since reading The Danger Within (1952), I'm glad I held off with reading it until now. I would not have appreciated it half as much without having sampled the work of other traditionalists in contemporary garb, like Douglas Clark and Roger Ormerod.

Katie Steelstock is a young, good looking village girl from West Hannington whose modeling career in London began landing her small, well paid parts in commercials and eventually became the face of The Seven O'Clock Show. An all-family quiz show that "combined general knowledge, popular music and a touch of sex" that turned Katie into "the two-dimensional friend of a million three-dimensional families" and "pin-up for a million adolescents." Katie's "bubbling, self-confident, friendly extrovert personality" transformed her into a nationwide TV celebrity, but she had a darker side to her character as "she liked to have people on the end of a string" that "she could give it a twitch from time to time and watch them dance." A pastime that can be very dangerous when done to the wrong people.

Although she works in London, Katie mostly resided in West Hannington with her mother Olivia and her two younger brothers, Walter and Peter, where she converted a former coachman's cottage into a private living quarters – giving her "that bit of privacy that all real artists need.” The Killing of Katie Steelstock begins on the day of the Boat and Tennis Club dance, which gave the story a hint of that old-world atmosphere of the Golden Age village mystery, introducing most of the important players in the tragedy discovered later that evening. The body of Katie is found lying near the boathouse with her head bashed in and it immediately becomes clear the local Chief Inspector Dandridge is completely out of his depth. An outraged Olivia Steelstock, sister of the Deputy Director of Public Prosecutions, pulls some strings and only takes a few phone calls for Detective Chief Superintendent Charlie Knott to be dispatched to West Hannington.

Superintendent Charlie Knott, "one of the self-appointed stars of the Murder Squad," appears on first glance to have a passing resemblance to the Great Detectives of yesteryear ("squat white-haired figure" with "an orchestration of grunts which could mean anything"). But appearances can be deceiving. Knott is one of those fallible police detectives ("...not an intellectual man"), like Inspector Morse, but "he could grasp the shape and outline of any crime he was called on to investigate." Was the criminal of professional or amateur or the nature of the motive, which is an instinct which had very rarely let him down. Knott's instinct points towards a local journalist, Jonathan Limbery, who uses the weekly Gazette as a pulpit for his outspoken views on authority ("he dislikes everybody who's older than he is, or better off"). Something that made him very popular with the schoolboys of the village whom he taught at Coverdales, before getting sacked. He was also involved with Katie and his alibi is not exactly fireproof. Knott is not the only the policeman investigating the case. Detective Sergeant Ian McCourt, "a cocky type who would be inclined to strike out a line on his own," which he does as he begins to investigate a big name in the village, George Mariner, while Sergeant Esdaile attempts to track down a typewriter – used to type the note that lured Katie to the boathouse. There's always the London end of the case and the scumbag photographer, Rodney "Rod the Sod" Ruoff, who helped Katie get her big break in show business. Not to mention two additional bodies drifting along in the background that (needlessly) muddy the waters even further. 

The Killing of Katie Steelstock is unmistakably told in that dark, gritty tone of the modern crime novel and presented as an up-to-date police procedural with the detectives taking fingerprints, making plaster casts of tire tracks and throwing out now quaint little references to 1980s computer technology. Novels from this period involving computers (e.g. Ellen Godfrey's Murder Behind Locked Doors, 1988) have acquired this historical quaintness over the past few decades, but meshes well with the traditional, Golden Age-style plot hidden underneath its modern-day trappings and characters. A plot that eventually culminating in a very brief, but intense, roller coaster of a courtroom drama with some unexpected, truly tragic turn of events. Gilbert invested in his characters to get this payoff, before telling the reader who really killed Katie Steelstock in the last chapter. A very well hidden murderer and somewhat of an old dodge, but you can work out the murderer's identity and motive from the clues and information dropped throughout the story. Admirably, Gilbert made the reader sympathize with the murderer, as a person, without condoning or minimizing the murders. Katie was hardly an angel, but even her worse actions hardly justified bashing in her skull. On the other hand, I didn't think Limbery deserved any sympathy as he's the only character who really deserved a caning by the end. Gilbert not only knew his way around a tricky plot, but a maze of human emotions as well. It gives a glimpse of what the Golden Age detective story could have turned into had it been allowed to evolve naturally pass the 1950s.

There are, however, one or two technical imperfections that need to be mentioned as they kept the book from a place in the first rank. One such problem is the mysterious murder weapon linking two of the murders, "a hole in his head which had been made by the same weapon which killed Katie," but the weapon in question is never even identified! I suspect the second body with an identical head wound was included to even the playing field for the defense later on in the story. That was a mistake. Just having Katie's murder would have stacked the odds in favor of the prosecution and added more tension to the courtroom scenes, but no matter how strong their case looks, the prosecution's case would have collapsed no matter what. So why not take advantage of it by making it look like the defense has no chance whatsoever? And it would have given that tragic twist even more of an impact. I also frowned a little at the fingerprint business towards the end, but liked how Gilbert foreshadowed it (SPOILER/ROT13: “Lbh bhtug gb xrrc hc gb qngr va gur grpuavdhrf bs lbhe cebsrffvba”). I think it would have helped, if the reader was shown part of the ending instead of being told about it afterwards.

But regardless of those minor, plot-technical imperfections, The Killing of Katie Steelstock is an excellent, updated take on the good, old British village mysteries of the past (c.f. Nicholas Brady's Ebenezer Investigates, 1934) told as a then contemporary police procedural – one that did not shy away from being uneasy or downright unpleasant. It's sole drawback is that it could have been an even tighter story with a bigger impact had the two other murders been cut out of the plot, but, as it stands, it can match the best works from the previously mentioned Douglas Clark and Roger Ormerod.