I
wrote "The
Locked Room Mystery & Impossible Crime Story in the 21st Century" that the first notable publication at the turn of the century was an
anthology, Mike Ashley's The Mammoth Book of Locked Room Mysteries
and Impossible Crimes (2000), which is an ambitious, somewhat
uneven collection – combining rarely collected stories with new
material. Somehow, I neglected to mention about a dozen more locked
room-themed anthologies have appeared since then. That's double the
number of anthologies published during the previous century. Not all
of them winners, to be sure, but a handful should be considered
standard works for anyone interested in building up their own "Locked
Room Library."

Ashley
repeated the trick of his first anthology with The Mammoth Book of
Perfect Crimes and Impossible Mysteries (2006), a mix of old and
commissioned stories, but was eventually demolished by Otto Penzler's
colossal The
Black Lizard Big Book of Locked Room Mysteries (2014). An
absolute unit of an anthology! Ye
Olde Book of Locked Room Conundrums (2016) deserves a
mention, I suppose. I think the most significant and important of
these new impossible crime anthologies came with the publication of
John Pugmire and Brian Skupin's The
Realm of the Impossible (2017). A collection of twenty-six
short stories from across the world interspersed with twelve
anecdotes of real-life locked room puzzles. A truly fantastic and
original anthology that nonetheless suffered two misfortunes: it came
early in the translation wave and the passing of Pugmire closing the
door on a potential sequel.So
was surprised, and incredibly pleased, when Crippen
& Landru announced a new anthology of locked room mystery
stories, All the Crime in the World (2026), edited by Gigi
Pandian and Tom
Mead – who "assembled a collection of international
experts" to explain miracles. A collection of fourteen short
stories either original to this anthology or their first appearance
in translation by authors from across the world. The expected
countries like America, Britain, France and Japan are represented,
but also Brazil, Singapore and (finally!) the Netherlands. What's
more, I really like how the locked globe on the cover with the key
sticking out is a nod to The Realm of the Impossible. So let's
dive into these new impossible crime stories and, as always, I'll try
to keep it brief.
The
first story is from Victor Bonini, a Brazilian-born author living in
New York, who used that city as a backdrop for "The Body on the
Rooftop." A body, wrapped in garbage bags, is spotted on the
rooftop of a high rise building by the residents of the adjacent
building. The victim turns out to be an unpopular manager/landlord,
but the problem is how the body ended up there as access to the
rooftop was blocked at the time. Only working key was in possession
of the young janitor, Lucas, who was recorded by the elevator camera
as the only person going up to the roof. So the neighbors who spotted
the body spring into action to clear Lucas from suspicion. I'm two
minds about this story, plotwise. Staging this type of tricky,
complicated impossible crime is always going to be a wire-walking act
across a slippery cord. Bonini didn't make it easier for himself by
placing a lot of strain on that cord by having everything and
everyone play into the murderer's hands, but on the other hand, I
appreciated the gusto of staging such a tricky, complicated
impossibility out in the open. On the rooftop of a high rise
building! And perfectly solvable, if you pay attention. So not a
modern classic of the impossible crime tale, but a good, solid
opening to this anthology.
Next
up is "The Legacy," a short story by Australian writer Sulari
Gentill, who tackles that beloved sub-trope of the locked room
mystery, a room-that-kills, inside a dual narrative – intertwining
past and present. In the present, Butch and Meg are renovating his
old family home when Meg comes across a dusty, crammed and forgotten
storage room. Meg thinks it is a waste of a room and wants to turn it
into nursery, but Butch tells her the room is where "Millicent
Mayfield killed herself in here in the nineteenth century" and
ever since "anyone who spent the night was dead by morning." The past narrative shows what happened in the year following the
death of Millicent and the man who was forced by her will to spend
every night in that room for a year. There is no detection as "The
Legacy" is a story that unravels itself, but still enjoyed it.
Josh
Pachter's "The Allegory of the Five Senses" is the third story in
both this anthology and a new series of historical short stories
about a real-life character, Dr. Joseph Guislain, who pioneered
psychiatry in Belgium and opened the Hospice Guislain in 1857. This
is, sort of, a historical series within a historical series as the
long-lost cases of Dr. Guislain are told by his assistant, Amandine
Caekebeke, to a journalist from Vrij België in 1917. During
previous visits, she told about "the apparently impossible
murder of Simon De Bakker" and this time about the time the
doctor solved a theft from the Museum voor Schone Kunsten. A painting
inexplicably disappeared from a locked and guarded gallery shortly
after they viewed it. Unfortunately, the solution is disappointingly
derivative made all the worse by trying to excuse it. Pachter
admitted this on his website, "I
turned a possible criticism into what I think is a clever Easter
egg." So more than a little disappointed as I loved "Sam
Buried Caesar" (1971) and was excited to see Pachter's name
among the contributors, but this was a poor showing.
The
next entry comes from Dutch mystery writer M.P.O.
Books, under his now open penname of "Anne
van Doorn," but have already reviewed "De man die wilde
vliegen" ("The Man Who Wanted to Fly") as part of the short
story collection Meer
mysteries voor Robbie Corbijn (More Mysteries for Robbie
Corbijn, 2021). Going over that review, I specifically
recommended "The Man Who Wanted to Fly" to be translated figuring
an international, genre-savvy audience would be more appreciative of
it. I hope this is one of those rare instances where most of you
agree. Fingers crossed the translation of Het
Delfts blauw mysterie (The Delft Blue Mystery, 2023)
finds a publisher soon!
Yamaguchi
Masaya is the mastermind behind the hybrid masterpiece Ikeru
shikabane no shi (Death of the Living Death, 1989) and
represents the shin honkaku movement with "Wabi no
misshitsu" ("The Wabi Locked Room") – originally published in
Nihon
satsujin jiken (The Japanese Murder Case, 1988). This
short impossible crime story, translated by Steve Steinbock, is part
of a hybrid mysteries taking place in an alternate, modern-day Japan "where rickshaws are as common as taxicabs, Samurai still
dominate civic life, and ninjas operate behind the scenes." The
protagonist of this series is Tokyo Sam, an American private eye, who
decided to make the country of his stepmother his new home and learns
about Japanese culture through his cases. "The Wabi Locked Room" revolves all around the traditionally Japanese tea ceremony taking up
two-thirds of the story, until a famous tea master is stabbed to
death inside a locked tea hut. So far, the story didn't disappoint
with the added interest that the victim was already dead when leading
the tea ceremony Sam attended. A double impossibility! Regrettably,
the solution is preposterous (even for a hybrid mystery) and the only
part justifying its inclusion here are the false-solutions. Yeah, I
know. A shin honkaku story in a locked room anthology that
doesn't deliver? I, too, was shocked!
Ovidia
Yu is a Singaporean mystery novelist of the historical Su
Lin series and a short-lived series of cozies featuring a
character named Aunty
Lee. Yu's contribution to this anthology, "Knock and Run," is
a story obviously set in modern times and falls under, what some
call, the hotel mystery. A woman, named Mrs. Diana Gowen, died
unexpectedly behind the locked door of her hotel room at the Bonsai
Palace Sentosa in Singapore and now her husband is raising hell
("your whole hotel chain... is finished"). So it's up to
Mr. Fang, hotel manager, and Lin Soong, owner of the Bonsai Palace
Hotels chain, to find out what happened in that room. This is
honestly not a bad story, which has neat little twist on a classic
murder method, but it's not strictly speaking a proper locked room
mystery.
S.A.
Cosby "The Price of Money" is a fun, old-fashioned locked room
murder in a modern setting. Aurelias "Riley" Rexroat, "a
criminology professor and part-time police consultant," is
helping out his girlfriend, Delphine, catering for a fancy birthday
party. Only problem is that the birthday boy is currently one of the
most hated men in the country, Jeffery Greenway, who has scammed a
ton of people out of their life savings and made a lot of dangerous
enemies. Riley notices the party lacks a party atmosphere as everyone
appears strained and uptight. Shortly after making his speech,
Greenway returns to his study to make a private call when a shot is
heard. They break down the locked door and find Greenway slumped over
his desk with a bullet in his head and a pistol near his hand. A
classical locked room situation with a variation on a trick you
probably have seen before. So not blistering original, when it comes
to the locked room-trick, but well executed and always enjoy seeing a
contemporary take on the classic Van Dine-Queen detective story.
Well,
well, well... and who do we have here? Yes, it's our homeboy and one
of the leading locked room specialists of the independent scene,
James
Scott Byrnside, who wrote "The Fourth Guest" for this
anthology. An inverted impossible crime story told from the
perspective of the murderer, Teddy Rose, who's a struggling with two
publications to his name – a "decent short story and a subpar
novella." Rose is acquainted with a far more successful mystery
novelist, Rachel Thorndyke, but he hated her for her success and
patronizing praise ("she loved the work of untalented
writers..."). She contacted Rose one day with the idea of
throwing a murder party at her home with herself as the victim of a
gruesome, bloody murder inside a locked room. What she could not have
anticipated is Rose using her locked room-trick to make her murder a
reality. What he didn't expect was Thorndyke to add a few clues and
surprises to the agreed upon plot. Such as inviting "the
Midwest's favorite sleuth" Rowan Manory and his right hand man
Walter Williams. A detective who also happens to be an expert when it
comes to handling impossible crimes.
This
particular locked room-trick is not the toughest nut Manory and
Williams had to crack, but the locked room-trick has that simplistic
cleverness complemented by the interesting, layered clueing. "The
Fourth Guest" pleasingly reminded me of "The
Detective Novelist Murder Case" from Motohiro Katou's Q.E.D.
vol. 33! The locked room is not the only hook why should read this
story, but definitely getting a Manory and Williams story told by an
ever so slightly unhinged killer. And what causes his downfall. Those
last two lines stung a little.
Similar
to Gentill's "The Legacy," Martin
Edwards' "Don't Look Back" is a dual narrative, of sorts, but
moving between a shorter space of time. The story begins at a
graveside with three names on the headstone, "two parents and a
daughter, all gone within the space of eighteen months," which
then turns to the disappearance of a drug dealer by the name of Zak
Rawson – who one day simply vanished without a trace. Rawson was
considered "a lowlife who had managed to stay out of prison by
the skin of his teeth" and neither the police nor the public
are overly concerned with his fate. So a good, short crime story with
a touch of Edgar Allan Poe, but honestly fail to see how it qualifies
as an impossible crime story.
Christopher
Huang is another Singaporean mystery writer whose contribution, "In
Broad Daylight, with Witnesses," takes the impossible crime out of
its closed quarters and out in the open. Tom Harvey is a now
reformed, ex-youthful delinquent who turned to writing detective
fiction allowing him to settle down in middle-class suburbia. This
story opens with Harvey discussing detective fiction with his
neighbors, the Hendersons, but the only mystery enthusiast in that
family is the eldest, soon to be married daughter. Gladys shows a
very refined taste ("it's the impossible ones that I like best")
and wonders if it would be possible to pull such a trick in broad
daylight with hundreds of witnesses. That's exactly what would happen
two weeks later during her wedding when her husband of a few hours is
shot dead. The apparent murderer is immediately apprehended, only for
the crime to turn into an impossible one when it turns out the fatal
bullet didn't come from the suspect's gun. Someone shot the groom
without being seen and it's up Harvey to figure out who did it and
how. Not too difficult to solve, but a pleasant story with an
entertaining detective.
Paul
Halter brings some much needed baroque to this locked room
anthology with "La mariée du pendu" ("The Hanged Man's
Bride"). The story begins in the condemned cell where an angry,
bitter Hugo Holmes is waiting to "be hanged for a crime he had
not committed." And the person he blames for this miscarriage
of justice is the hanging judge, Henry Palgrave ("he would be
destroyed by occult forces"). Several years later, sometime in
the early 1960s, Dr. Alan Twist is listening at the London's Hades
Club to Superintendent Charles Cullen tell him about his tragic visit
to Judge Palgrave.
Judge
Palgrave recently retired and believed someone had it out for him,
but when Cullen arrived, the judge had retreated to the
rustic-looking outbuilding in garden used a private study. But when
the family announce Cullen, they get no response and have to bust
open the door. What they find inside is the judge lying on the floor
with a bullet wound to the temple and a gun nearby. So it looks like
suicide as no killer could have gotten out of the locked outbuilding,
or hiding somewhere inside, but the fingerprints on the murder weapon
turns this suicide into a murder with two impossibilities – because
the fingerprints belong to Hugo Holmes. A man who was hanged and
buried three years ago! Dr. Twist has a tricky, involved and
multi-layered locked room-trick to pick apart. Yes, there's a crude
quality to this story's locked room mechanics, but enjoyed its
inclusion as most authors here shied away from such elaborate tricks
and baroque plotting. I also liked that the solution can be taken as
an alternative solution for (SPOILER/ROT13)
gur qrnq zna'f xabpx ol wbua qvpxfba pnee. Only negative is
that this story made me miss John Pugmire.
Shelly
Dickson Carr is the granddaughter of the greatest detective novelist
who ever lived, John
Dickson Carr, who not only continues a family tradition with her
contribution, "Murder in Harvard Yard," but family business. The
reason is that this short story could easily have been titled "Henry
Merrivale, the College Years." The setting of the story is Harvard
where a young exchange student from Oxford, named Mr. Henry
Merrivale, becomes involved with the suspicious death of the campus
bully, Septimus Finch. Just two problems: the victim is the son of
the Under Secretary of the Navy and was found behind a locked door.
The story then goes over what happened preceding the body's discovery
and getting to see this younger incarnation of Merrivale, "twenty-one
and full of cocksure bravado," is the main attraction of this
short story. I kind of want to see more of young Merrivale.
Vaseem
Khan's penultimate short story, "A Distinctive Man," is part of
the Ashwin Chopra series. A retired police inspector turned private
investigator who has a baby elephant, named Ganesha, who accompanies
him on cases. Chopra is hired by a hotel owner, Tarun Vyas, who had a
guest die from "an allergic reaction to a trace amount of ground
almonds" inside a locked and bolted hotel room. He needs to
know what happened in order to save his hotel. The victim is Derek
Niven, an Englishman, who was very careful about his allergy and
could not have been given the ground almonds during the evening meal.
Afterwards, Niven retreated to his room that he locked and bolted.
Not to mention the whole room was practically contaminated with
ground almond. How was it done and by whom? Niven was there with
three other people giving Chopra three suspects. This is one of the
shorter stories in the anthology, but the locked room problem is
neatly posed with an original and satisfying solution. I liked how
this story feels like a case from Gosho Aoyama's Case
Closed series.
So
we come at the Main Event of All the Crime in the World: "The
Problem of the Poisoned Garden" by the co-editors Gigi Pandian and
Tom Mead.
I
wondered what form their collaboration would take. I was hoping on a
crossover between their two magician detectives. Hey, Bill
Pronzini and Marcia
Muller's Beyond
the Grave (1986) is a crossover between two series a century
apart, but title also made it possible it was a pastiche of the Dr.
Sam Hawthorne series as an homage to Edward
D. Hoch. Pandian and Mead opted for a standalone story with two
new characters. A world-renowned criminologist referred to simply as
the Professor and his American assistant, Caroline Renwick, who
travel to Ramscar Abbey to meet Avery Corsair. A botanist who put on
trial some forty years ago for poisoning his wife and acquitted, but
suspicion of murder never left him. Recently, the attic was cleared
out and a journal was found with the last entry written on the
morning she died in 1979. Corsair believes the entry proves his
innocence. During their visit, Corsair is strangled while alone in
his poison garden "penned in by walls eight feet tall, garlanded
with iron spikes" guarded by "two imperious figures in
matching uniforms." Not a bad locked room/closed garden to
close out this anthology, but even better is what the authors have
hidden underneath it. So good it makes we want to forgive something I
normally frown upon.
So,
all in all, All in the Crime in the World is the expected
mixed bag that most anthologies tend to be, but this time not because
it has a few bad stories or real stinkers. On the contrary, the
good-to-bad ratio is leans heavily towards the good, but not every
story should have qualified for this anthology and not every story
was strong on the locked rooms and impossible crimes. However, the
best stories from Bonini, Byrnside, Cosby, Van Doorn, Halter, Khan
and the editors firmly places All the Crime in the World above
other locked room-themed anthologies that have been published since
The Realm of the Impossible.