The 81st volume of Gosho Aoyama's Case Closed, known outside of the English-speaking world as Detective Conan, begins where the previous volume ended with Doc Agasa taking Conan and the Junior Detective League to the Flower Festival in the public park – where they meet Jodie Sterling to discuss the events from vol. 78. There is a pickpocket slinking through the crowd of cherry blossom viewers and Doc Agasa witnesses a murder when he came out of the restroom.
Doc Agasa thought he saw someone hammering a stake into the ground, "a silhouette" wearing "a hat and holding a thin stick about a foot long," who limped away and disappeared into the crowd. After the incident, Doc Agasa discovers the body of a woman. A notorious pickpocket the police has been after for some time, but a straightforward case of a pickpocket getting brutally mugged herself quickly turns into a much more complicated and tricky problem. The crime scene is a little distance away from the park, which is immediately closed off by the police and should trap the murderer inside. They retrieve the stolen, emptied wallets in the trashcans, netting them three potential suspects, but none of the three suspects have a limp or carrying "a foot-long stick." A weapon that's nowhere to be found in the park or shrine. And why did the three suspects talked to the Junior Detective League around the time of the murder?The solution is a work of beauty as it craftily dovetails the nature of the invisible weapon with how it disposed, why Doc Agasa saw the murderer limping away and why it was necessary to talk to Conan and his friends – only one aspect of the motive seemed a little iffy. Other than that this is one of the better, pure detective stories in the series with an original take on the impossible problem and a plot-thread tied directly to the ongoing storyline. And, on top of that, the Junior Detective League were not completely useless here. A winner!
The second, three-chapter story, titled respectively "The Barroom Detective Takes a Case," "The Barroom Detective Makes a Deduction" and "The Barroom Detective Solves the Case," is a long overdue Richard Moore centric case. Richard Moore accepted a job from the bartender of the Blue Parrot, Yuzuki Fukui, who has been hearing a pop, "like a champagne bottle," which is always followed by "a citrus scent." So she assumed customers were sneaking in bottles, but she kept an eye on the clientele and didn't catch anyone drinking wine or champagne. The only customers who were always around when it happened was a corporate executive and three of his downtrodden underlings. Moore takes the case by sitting at the bar smoking cigarettes, drinking gimlets and butchering Raymond Chandler with his internal monologue ("my heart throbs to the cool rhythms of jazz on the speakers" and "she must think I'm the great sleuth Philip Marlowe").
Rachel sends Conan to the Blue Parrot to tell her father dinner is getting cold, but Conan arrives at the bar right at the time the executive is found dead slumped over the bar. Stabbed in the neck with something sharp and toxic. So the bar is searched and the three suspects patted down, but every possible weapon (like darts) turn out to be clean. Another so-called invisible weapon case ("just like the pickpocket case the other day") with the only difference that the trick here seemed needlessly complicated. Surely the same effect could have been achieved in a less risky, roundabout way. Nonetheless, a good, fun little story with a splendid ending giving Sleeping Moore's take on why he blackouts when he "solves" a case.
The third story, more or less, picks up immediately after the second story as Conan realizes something about the pickpocket case, which is now tied to the Hostage Case (vol. 65) and Mystery Train Case from the previously mentioned vol. 78 – bringing "Bourbon" and "Vermouth" back into the picture. Conan is soon wrapped up in another murder case when he and Rachel bump into Masumi Sera. Sera is hired by the older sister of school friend, Rumi Kitao, who's dating a senior college student, Kenya Settsu, but "rumor has it he's a player who's two-timing her with his ex," Waka Hashitani. Rumi asked Sera to check him out ("cheating... the private eye's bread and butter") and took the opportunity to recruit Rachel and Conan. This leads them to finding Waka's bludgeoned body in the chloroform fume filled bathroom of her apartment wearing nothing more than a towel and a mudpack.
Just like the first story, this has all the appearance of a routine story that can be found in every volume of the series, but there's more to the story than is apparent on the surface. Firstly, Sera acted wonderfully as a rival detective by proposing a false-solution, which was sound and convincing enough, but Conan has to correct her deductions (as Jimmy) over the phone by pointing out the dying message. A hidden, unsuspected dying message that nonetheless had been strongly hinted at throughout the story. Logically revealing the only person who could have done it. Secondly, the story reinforces the question how much Sera really knows, or suspects, regarding Conan's identity. And who's calling and texting? That question is (sort of) answered towards the end and during the next story, but it's an answer that raises more questions than it answers.
The fourth and final story is actually a complete one (hurrah) and brings Conan, Rachel, Serena and Sera to the bowling alley where they meet two school teachers. A third teacher had trouble holding his liquor, got into a fight and is now passed out in the car, but the troublesome gym teacher goes missing and is found sometime later inside a porta potty – as "a drowned corpse." A bizarre scene, to be sure, but, even without figuring out how the trick was done, because the method made the murderer standout. I appreciated the murderer's motive helped justify employing such a risky, complicated trick, but the Conan/Sera storyline is what gave the story its interest.
So very little to complain about except for the repetitive motive cropping up in all, but one, of the four stories. Other than that this another rock solid volume perfectly balancing the stronger, plot-driven standalone cases with the multiple, character-driven storylines stretching across the series.
I wish someone would make a myth-buster-style show testing the various tricks in Conan and other impossible crime stories. I think it would make an interesting youtube show. I remember Ho-ling mentioned that Aoyama Gosho often tested his tricks with his editors before writing the stories. On that note, there is also a hilarious Kindaichi spin-off parody: 'Kindaichi Shounen no Jikenbo Gaiden: Hannin-tachi no Jikenbo. ' Basically, it retells many cases from the manga, but from the culprit's perspective. It is hilarious to see how they tried to do a lot of the tricks in the manga, which is often physically demanding.
ReplyDeleteI believe Jim is considering to do exactly that with his own locked room-trick from The Red Death Murders, because we wouldn't shut up about it needing a diagram. Ho-Ling has blogged about that spin-off series. The retelling of House of Wax sounded intriguing as it shows the murderer creating and getting attached to the wax dolls. It's a great concept and an original addition to a long-running series.
DeleteIn the Japanese amusement show Suiyoubi no Downtown, they even had "Mr. Sasuke", a veteran participant of Sasuke (Ninja Warrior) try re-enact some of the murder tricks from Kindaichi Shounen, showing again how insanely difficult it is XD
DeleteThe parody series is really funny, though it really is "just for fans". Which reminds me that earlier this week, the author tweeted about a recent script change in the official app version which was made without his approval. In the original version, the joke was the murderer thought Hajime reminded her of Doumoto Tsuyoshi, Matsumoto Jun, Kamenashi Kazuya or Yamada Ryousuke (the four actors who have played Hajime in the various television series). But this week, they added the name of the actor who'll be playing Hajime in the new series which starts this weekend :P
Also leaving this here: trying out whether the trick from the Detective Conan original The Cursed Masks Laugh Coldly is doable :P https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aPRJfW0fwZo
I really enjoyed that video, but they should have used sturdier material to give the trick a chance to work. Now it's like they tried to prove you can bludgeon someone with a role of coins by using a stack of rubber bands. I distinctly remember a wooden-ish sound to the trick. Anyway, I appreciate the attempt and thanks for sharing!
DeleteI just watched 'The Cursed Masks Laugh Coldly,' and the locked-room trick is genuinely brilliant. However, the youtube video is hilarious. Yeah, a sturdier material might work, but the video showed a lot of flaws to the trick. Besides being very physically demanding, it is also really noisy. Thanks, Ho-ling, for sharing the link. I noticed that the channel also had several more Conan locked-room tricks experiments. This is a really fun idea for a channel. As a fan of Sasuke, I can only imagine how funny it is to see Mr. Sasuke attempting Kindaichi tricks.
DeleteGood review, TomCat! I happened to join a Detective Conan community recently where, apparently, you and Ho-Ling are known by some members as respectable voices in the Case Closed-o-sphere... I was surprised to join a community that has nothing to do with you and find that a person or two had some strong opinions about your favorite locked-room mysteries in the series! The second of which, by the way, I am quickly approaching...
ReplyDeleteWe have been practically the only one's who consistently discussed, reviewed and promoted the series outside of the conan-a-sphere, but surprised nonetheless Ho-Ling and I have a voice in a community we didn't even know existed. Any strong opinions floating around on my boss theory?
DeleteI would like to know the problem they had with my picks. I discovered Detective Conan and anime/manga mysteries in general as a fan of Golden Age detective fiction, but Detective Conan fans usually were introduced to the genre through anime/manga. So comparing notes could be interesting.
I haven't heard anything about your Boss theory, but most people seem to think VERY highly of the first 10 volumes, and I've seen arbitrary numbers for when the series gets bad but there's this idea of "the series should have ended after volume 30/40/50, none of the cases after this point are good", etc. etc. Many people told me that my perspective on the early series was "refreshing", because apparently it's just the default that Detective Conan fans are disillusioned with the series due to an extreme disdain for the later volumes.
DeleteI was also surprised to find a sizable portion of people who skip any "filler" case or don't even pay attention to the mysteries and exclusively read Detective Conan for the character interactions and overarching narrative.
Your Volume 60 favorite impossible crime was merely summed up as "a hot take", or "a decent story with nothing special".
Also, I bragged that I know you and Ho-Ling. :P
Oh, yes, and one person, whose soul criterion for doing so was "I've read all of Sherlock Holmes twice", pretty egregiously contradicted me on my understanding of the mystery genre and pretended as if they had a tighter understanding on the definition of "fairplay" than of all people Martin Edwards (whose essays I brought up).
DeleteSole* criterion... Not soul
DeleteThey sound like me during my infancy as a mystery fan when I wanted everything to be either like Baantjer or Christie and dismissed practically everything published after 1950. A phase most of us go through before our personal taste matures and get fine-tuned, but they look to be stuck in a single series. That would explain why they prefer the earlier volumes, because it reminds them of when they still enjoyed the series. You know my opinion on those early volumes and the stumbling block they form for mystery fans, like us, to get to all the good stuff later on in the series.
DeleteAnother explanation is the sizable portion, you mentioned, who prefer Detective Conan for the cast of characters and their interactions. You can find mystery fans who prefer character over plot even around these parts, but, if you only read or watch this series for the characters, their frustration is kind of understandable. The main storyline has been unfolding at a snail's pace and commented in the past that the whole Conan/Jimmy charade towards Rachel should have ended a good thirty volumes ago.
However, I'm an unapologetic plot guy and locked room fanboy who prefers the double digit volumes and believes "The Poisonous Coffee Case" to be a masterpiece of impossible crime fiction. So no idea how my hot takes makes me a respectable voice in their community.
“Oh, yes, and one person, whose soul criterion for doing so was "I've read all of Sherlock Holmes twice", pretty egregiously contradicted me on my understanding of the mystery genre and pretended as if they had a tighter understanding on the definition of "fairplay" than of all people Martin Edwards (whose essays I brought up).”
DeleteSome of you frown or even laugh every time I ask for a breaking wheel or gibbet cage, but this is the kind of behavior you get when you don't have a brutal inquisition every now and then.
To be honest, I stay away from the Conan fan community because I'm just afraid of accidentally coming across spoilers, due to the lag between the release of the serialized chapters and the collected volumes, and me generally waiting for the home video release of each year's film. It's just too risky to even peek at Conan communities :P
Delete