4/27/20

The Longstreet Legacy (1951) by Douglas Ashe

John Franklin Bardin was an American crime writer best remembered today as the author of three early psychological thrillers, whose admirers were as diverse as Edmund Crispin and Julian Symons, but, under the name "Gregory Tree," he produced two courtroom dramas and an impossible crime novel, A Shroud for Grandmama (1951) – which comes with all the trappings of a gloomy, old-fashioned Gothic romance. A Shroud for Grandmama was reprinted under yet another penname, namely "Douglas Ashe," as The Longstreet Legacy.

Back in 2014, John Norris, of Pretty Sinister Books, posted a review on his blog calling A Shroud for Grandmama "a lively and entertaining detective" with a fantastic and engaging narrator, but warned that it "is somewhat scarce in either hardcover or paperback." So the book lingered on my wishlist, like an earthbound spirit, when recently, I lucked upon an inexpensive, well-worn copy.

Miss Abigail Longstreet is a young, beautiful woman in her late twenties, but speaks and dresses as a woman from the turn-of-the-century. Abigail preferred "the joys of introspection and the lady arts" to the people of her own age and the modern world, which she deemed as "vulgar and footling." This meant she lived quite a solitary existence, but not to the same extent as her eccentric grandmother, Ella Longstreet, who lives like a hermit in a dark, imposing New York mansion – where she has denied the existence of the outside world for the past fifteen years. Abigail is the only line of communication between her grandmother and their greedy relatives who are always in need of money. And this is why she's the only one of the family who knows that Ella is completely blind.

So, naturally, she was quite perplexed when a man, Arthur Crump, turned up on her doorstep with a crumpled note, saying "come in haste," with her grandmother's engraved wedding wrapped inside. Crump tells her the package had struck his head in the streets and thinks it had been thrown at him from an upstairs window, which could mean that her grandmother is in trouble. Nothing could have prepared Abigail for what she found when crossing the threshold of the great house where she had spent her girlhood.

Ella Longstreet's emaciated, nearly naked body, scantily dressed in "one of those scandalous swimming suits," a bikini, lying at the bottom of the staircase on the dust covered parquetry of the long, two-storied hallway, but the body is surrounded by "a circle of waltzing footprints" – as if "someone had gone round it" in "a frenzied haste." Inexplicably, there were no other footprints going to, or leaving, the circle on the thick layer of dust carpeting the hallway! Abigail does exactly what her grandmother would have wanted, avoiding a scandal, by destroying the evidence and carrying her grandmother's body to her bedroom to put some decent clothes on her to face the undertaker. However, she discovers that the closet is empty with the exception of a stiff, grim-looking funeral shroud!

Shortly after Abigail finished tidying up the crime scene, the doorbell pealed and she found Deputy Chief Inspector Stephen Eliot standing on the doorstep.

According to Eliot, there are more than a thousand known recluses, on all levels of society, in the jurisdiction of Manhattan and Ella Longstreet was "the wealthiest and most notorious." A nominal supervision is kept of all of them, wherever possible. Abigail learns from Eliot that the house of her grandmother resembled a busy thoroughfare on the day of her dead, which attracted the attention of the beat cops.

Apparently, the whole family visited Ella that day with a written invitation in hand that also contained references to the notorious family ghost, Sybil. A poltergeist with an undying love for dancing and pelting people with objects.

An utterly bizarre and impossible problem, but Eliot is a sharp, tricky customer who loves to set out verbal traps and somewhat reminded me of Lt. Columbo. His questioning of the family is illuminating to both Abigail and the reader. Abigail comes to see many of her relatives in a different light and learns more about herself than she would have been comfortable with in the first chapter, but these interviews also provide the reader with pieces of the puzzle, which gives answers to some of the more outre aspects of the case – such as why the body was dressed in a bikini. Slowly, but surely, a picture begins to emerge of the truth and the keen-eyed reader will be able to fill-in the blank spaces, but beware the slippery red herring. Because your ego can break its neck when you slip on the neatly positioned red herrings in this story! Yeah, I sort of Roger Sheringhamed it.

But, for me, the absolute highlight of The Longstreet Legacy was not the who, or why, but how the murderer was able to place the body in a circle of footprints without disturbing the dust that covered the rest of the floor. A fantastic and entirely new solution to the no-footprints problem. However, while the solution is entirely original, you can easily see which well-known impossible crime novel gave Bardin the idea, which is to his credit, because I would have never thought of using it like that in a million years!

So, on this count alone, The Longstreet Legacy comes highly recommended to fans of the impossible crime story and particularly those fans with a special affinity for the no-footprints puzzle.

The Longstreet Legacy is an excellent throwback, or homage, to the turn-of-the-century Gothic tale, full of dark, long-held secrets, a ghost and family skeletons, but told with a traditional slant on it and a great detective who cuts through the web of lies and deceit. Honestly, my only complaint is how fast I burned through the pages of this immensely enjoyable detective yarn and I'm baffled that it has been out-of-print for so many decades. It deserves to be reprinted. But, in the mean time, I recommend you keep an eye out for an affordable, secondhand copy, because you want to have this one in your collection.

15 comments:

  1. Excellent book! So glad you found a copy. I loved this one. Such a surprise. I hadn't any expectations and it delivered a hundredfold. It's VERY different from his psychological thrillers under his own name and the "Gregory Tree" courtroom mysteries.

    Back in 2014 I tried to get all the Tree books plus this one reprinted, but Bardin's son is sort of contentious and is holding on tight to the rights. I got some ambiguous replies. I vaguely recall that he wasn't interested in having the Ashe book reissued and that he was ambivalent about the Tree books selling. I said that we would put his father's name on them and not the pseudonyms and he just stopped replying to me. One of the most frustrating endeavors which led me to completely abandon pursuing rights for reprints. Someone else may have luck, but I doubt it.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. So he's embarrassed that his father wrote detective and thriller novels? What a shame, since there's nothing to be ashamed of. This is a genuine classic and deserves to be reprinted, because there are so many readers today who would enjoy it. JJ would go nuts over the footprints-in-the-dust trick!

      Delete
  2. This sounds superb! You had me when you referenced Columbo but this just seems wonderfully odd and I am really interested to find out how the dust-covered floor problem is resolved.
    The prices are too high for me right now but I'll add it to my list of titles to keep an eye out for.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The impossibility here is original in both presentation and solution, which alone should make it a priority on your wishlist, but the whole story was just great. I hope you're able to find an affordable copy!

      Delete
    2. It does sound incredible. I will keep a careful watch and hope I get lucky!

      Delete
  3. I have read the three novels under the Bardin pen name but I never knew he had others. Thanks for an intriguing post.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. My pleasure! Hope you can find a copy or it gets reprinted.

      Delete
    2. Ah, how quickly we forget. In 2018 I left Kate a comment on her post for The Last of Philip Banter about this book and the Gregory Tree books as well. Gave her all the Bardin alter ego info and the alternate titles. [grumble, grumble]

      Delete
  4. Thanks for the review. I was just starting to feel sorry for myself that I would never get to read this, but when I checked my Bardin section I found that I already had a hardcover copy of the first edition (1951) by Scribner's. This hardcover is printed under the Douglas Ashe pseudonym. The English hardcover seems to have come out about a year later, but was published under the Gregory Tree pseudonym. Your review is so positive I will have to put it at the top of my reading list.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Now that's what I call a stroke of prescient luck! You won't be disappointed, I guarantee it. :)

      Delete
  5. When I was looking at the top of your page on my computer under Norton Safe Search, I noted that Norton Security listed your site as "suspect"! I pulled up information about it at the Norton site, and it said something about your site being an annoyance but not dangerous! There is a means of disputing this with them if you want to.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you for letting me know, Anon. The problem has now been resolved.

      Delete
  6. "However, while the solution is entirely original, you can easily see which well-known impossible crime novel gave Bardin the idea"...What novel would this be? I don't think I'll ever be able to get this book, so maybe the best I can do is imagine how the trick was done.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. That's a terrible idea! When you know the solution, you can see where he got the idea and how it could be used in a completely different way, but using that novel to reconstruct Bardin's solution won't get you very far. Remember, I read John Norris' review in 2014 and only recently came across a copy. So why spoil it for yourself?

      But if you insist (ROT13): gur jryy-xabja vzcbffvoyr pevzr abiry vf Pnegre Qvpxfba'f Fur Qvrq n Ynql.

      Delete
    2. Alright, you got me. That request was a thinly-veiled attempt to get another 'well-known impossible crime novel' on my reading list. I've only read like three works out of the greatest GAD authors with a couple of short stories (Fr. Brown's) and 'impossible footprints murder' lures me in the most.

      You're right, I don't get very far reconstructing Bardin's solution with what I know of that novel and Longstreet Legacy. Didn't even know you can modify that solution to a house! Thank you.

      Delete