Ooyama Seiichiro is a Japanese mystery writer specialized in themes series and short story collections, best known today for the "Alibi Cracking, At Your Service" series, who debuted on the e-NOVELS website with a pastiche of John Dickson Carr's Dr. Gideon Fell – entitled "Kanojo ga Patience wo korosu hazu ga nai" ("She Wouldn't Kill Patience," 2002). The short story obviously is a homage to He Wouldn't Kill Patience (1944; as by "Carter Dickson"), which was Carr's answer to Clayton Rawson's challenge to craft a locked room mystery where the crime scene is sealed on the inside with tape. Rawson provided his own answer in the short story "From Another World" (1948) and recently A. Carver tackled the problem of a murderer inexplicably escaping from multiple, tape-shut rooms with The Author is Dead (2022). Ooyama Seiichiro's "She Wouldn't Kill Patience" is a fascinating addition to this sub-category of the locked room mystery.
"She Wouldn't Kill Patience" opens one evening in the study of Dr. Fell, Number I Adelphi Terrace, where he's entertaining Superintendent Hadley, Sergeant Higgins and the solicitor Frank Morstan. Dr. Fell notices something is on the solicitor's mind.
Frank Morstan has recently gotten engaged to Marjorie Copperfield, but so has her mother and his future mother-in-law, the long-widowed and wealthy Mrs. Marie Copperfield – which came as a surprise, or shock, to everyone. The man in question is a middle-aged, French historian and lecturer, Georges Lefebvre, who's ten years her junior and viewed with suspicion ("perhaps he is after the Mrs. Copperfield's money"). Not without reason. Superintendent Hadley recognizes a French serial killer and fugitive, named Charles Raspail, in Morstan's description of Georges Lefebvre. Hadley calls Raspail "the rebirth of Henri Désiré Landru from his homeland, or George Joseph Smith of England," who had three wives die under mysterious circumstances. Only difference between him and those two is Raspail is "much more clever and cunning" as he varied his methods and techniques. An overdose of sleeping medication or a fall from a third-floor balcony. So it took some time for the authorities to catch on, but, when they finally cottoned on, Raspail fled to England and simply disappeared.
So, knowing what they know now, Mrs. Copperfield is certainly going to be targeted next. Hadley orders Higgins to keep an eye on the current M. Lefebvre, which they go get the file at Scotland Yard to convince Mrs. Copperfield. However, they arrive too late. Mrs. Copperfield is discovered dead in her bedroom with the gas-tap screwed open to a maximum with the door and windows "sealed tightly by long, thin strips of vellum pasted along the gaps." Obviously suicide. However, Mrs. Copperfield is not the only body in the gas-filled room. Near the gas-tap stood the birdcage with Mrs. Copperfield's parrot, Patience, lying at the bottom pining for the fjords. Marjorie is sure the dead parrot proves her mother was murdered as "my mother wouldn't kill Patience" ("...she hoped it would live the rest of it out in peace"). But how? Even Dr. Fell has to admit, "I know many methods to lock a room from the outside, but this is the first time I see it sealed."
The locked room-trick is a real humdinger! Sure, you can call the trick a new wrinkle on an old chestnut, but really enjoyed how this idea was applied to the puzzle of the tape-sealed room. More importantly, "She Wouldn't Kill Patience" is not an impossible crime tale where the murderer is easily spotted and the trick carrying the whole plot. Ooyama Seiichiro refused to go with the obvious throughout the story, which made for an excellent denouement as Dr. Fell exposed both the truth and pointing out the killer. My only complaint is that motive felt a trifle weak when held next to the rather ingenious and involved method, which required a weightier motive to justify it. Other than that, "She Wouldn't Kill Patience" is a first-class locked room mystery and exactly what pastiches should aspire to be. A story written with love and respect for the original.
Note for the curious: you're probably wondering where you can find and read this story. Someone emailed me this unofficial translation to read and review, if I wanted to review the story. I decided to review it simply to try and generate some attention for Ooyama Seiichiro, because I would love to see official translations of "The Red Museum" and "The Locked Room Collector" series.
Dang I was hoping to be the first to talk about this story in my Top 5 Taped Rooms post in a few weeks oh whale. It's such an awesome story though, so glad to see more awareness of it.
ReplyDeleteHonestly, I've entertained the thought of trying to translating one of Ooyama's collections since I love the work of his I've seen, but I doubt I have the time or skills for it right now.
A Top 5 Taped Rooms? I currently know of four tape-sealed room, Dickson's He Wouldn't Kill Patience, Rawson's "From Another World," Carver's The Author is Dead and this short story, but I can't think of a fifth novel or short story. Unless you're going for a twofer with your fifth pick and include those two Detective Conan stories with the taped bathroom and car? Either way, you'e piqued my interest!
DeleteThe fifth would be episode 2 "The Locked-Room" from the Japanese drama "The Locked-Room" adapted from *The Glass Hammer* short stories.
DeleteBelieve it or not there's even a SIXTH which I'm only including as an honorable mention cause the solution is kinda lame. I hadn't heard of the Detective Conan examples before
DeleteDon't expect too much from the Detective Conan examples (vol. 20 and 49), which aren't bad stories, but the tape-sealed bathroom/car tricks are both variations of another, better-known taped room story. Just two more and you can do a top 10!
DeleteHold on a minute! I just remembered another example: H.C. Kincaid's 1950 short story "Murder on a Bet." I reviewed it on this blog and the story is pretty good take on the tape-sealed room conundrum! No idea how that one slipped my mind. Anyway... that's nine and counting!
Dug around for a few minutes and found two more that completely slipped my mind: another tape-sealed car mystery can be found in Detective Conan, vol. 70 and Szu-Yen Lin's "The Miracle on Christmas Eve" has a locked room in which the window is sealed shut with tape. So instead of a top 5, you can now rank them from best to worst.
DeleteThanks for shouting out my review of Alibi-Cracking! It's a show I continue to appreciate more the more I look back on it. This is a great review of a story from Ōyama that I desperately need to read.
ReplyDeleteYou might have heard but apparently they broadcasted a special episode recently. No idea when it will be watchable though
DeleteI desperately need more Ooyama Seiichiro translations.
Delete