"You've been dreaming... bodies are always being found in libraries in books. I've never known a case in real life."- Colonel Bantry (Agatha Christie's The Body in the Library, 1942)
Comes a Stranger (1938) is the eleventh mystery in E.R.
Punshon's Detective-Sergeant Bobby Owen series and belonged to a cluster of
incredibly rare titles, which come with a three-or four digit prize-tag
attached to them – resulting in a limited circulation among collectors on the
secondhand book market. However, the key word here is "belonged."
Dean
Street Press is going to reissue yet another batch of Bobby Owen novels,
which are scheduled for release early next month. Our very own genre historian,
Curt Evans, provided the
introductions, but Comes a Stranger also has an interesting after word adding
some historical annotations to the plot – as well as mentioning the work of
other mystery writers that were inspired by the same event. But this part can't
be mentioned without spoiling a vital element of the plot. So I won't. Luckily,
there's more than enough material to drone on about between the pages of this
book.
In the book immediately preceding this
one, Dictator's Way (1938), Bobby Owen followed in the footsteps of Dorothy
L. Sayers' Lord Peter Wimsey and Ngaio
Marsh's Inspector Roderick Alleyn by falling in love with one of the
suspects: the lovely owner of chic London hat shop named Olive Farrar.
Interestingly, Alleyn and Agatha Troy met in Artists in Crime
(1938), which was published in the same year as Dictator's Way and Comes
a Stronger, but nearly a decade behind Sayers' Strong
Poison (1930) – a book that seems to have saved many detectives from
the celibate life of Sherlock Holmes, Father Brown and Dr. John Thorndyke.
The engagement between Bobby Owen and
Olive Farrar has come to the attention of Miss Kayne, an old acquaintance of
the latter, who invited the couple to spend a week at her place in Wynton
Village, which is also the home of the world-renowned Kayne Library.
Miss Kayne's late-father had spend years
in building up the library and has acquired the illustrious reputation of being "the finest collection of books in private hands." It contains the "whole
history of early European printing" and "the birth of European thought,"
which tell the story of "the growth of the human mind during those years"
– making it a modern Library of Alexandria. Under the "careful and somewhat
complicated will" of Miss Kayne's father, there's an assurance that the
library is kept together. However, this pits the interest of several interested
parties against each other.
A crabby, grouchy bibliographical
scholar, Mr. Broast, presides over the famous library and loves to act as its
owner, but under the will he's only an employee and has to deal with monthly
inspections from the co-trustees of the library – Mr. Nathaniel "Nat" Kayne and
Sir William Winders.
The former is Miss Kayne's cousin and he
would love nothing more than to cash in one the library’s reputation by selling
off the books to the University of Wales. The latter is a rival collector who
was "part dearest friend and colleague" and "part deadliest enemy and
hated and dreaded rival," who would leap at an opportunity to replace Mr.
Broast with one of his own man.
Well, it's against this backdrop, in
combination with a visit from a real-life Scotland Yard detective, that things
begin to happen all of a sudden, which commences with a report that a body has
been spotted in the library. I say spotted, because discovered isn't the right
word.
There's an American gentleman, Bertram A.
Virtue, who saw a blood-covered body of a man through the grated window of the
library. However, a thorough examination of the library failed to uncover as
much as a single drop of spilled blood, but, strangely enough, the report
coincides with the discovery of a murdered man in a sunken lane in the surrounding
woods – which was clearly murder going by the bullet holes in the body.
Bobby Owen is allowed to stay on at the
village to assist the local authorities and slowly, but surely, begins to
unravel the case, which has many interesting, seemingly baffling aspects about
it. Why did the description of the apparent non-existent body in the library match
a photograph in possession of Mr. Broast's giggling secretary, Miss Perkins? Why
did Bobby Owen receive a box filled with forgot-me-nots? Is there a personal
motive for the murder or is it tied to printed treasures stored in the library?
Does any of this pertain to the "perfect murder" Miss Kayne alluded to in a
conversation with Owen? And would it have killed the murderer to take a couple
of shooting lessons, before emptying an entire magazine in the second victim?
That's just lazy and sloppy work.
Punshon ties the entire bundle of
plot-threads together with the skill and grace one expects from a novelist, but
also has the air of a researcher/bibliographical scholar as it has many tidbits
about the history of the printing press, rare editions and book hunting – which
is compared with the work of a detective. It gave the novel a character of its
own.
So, in that regard, Comes a Stranger
is an absolute must-read for fans of the so-called "bibliomysteries,"
but let the reader be warned: some scenes towards the end of the book might be considered
trigger emotions of heavy dread. It's not what you think. It's much, much worse!
The only smudge on the overall plot (IMHO)
was why the first (shooting) victim died and the lack of adequate clueing to that
answer, which therefore became a rather cheap, somewhat unfair method to divert
attention away from the murderer. There was more than enough in the book to compensate
for this slight imperfection, but, as a bit of nitpicker, I was mildly annoyed
considering the quality of the overall plot.
Otherwise, I heartily welcome Comes a
Stranger back into circulation.
I'll be back soon with a review that, hopefully, wasn't slapped together by a sleep-deprived mind, but, in the meantime, you might want to be enticed by my previous reviews of
Punshon's Crossword Puzzle (1934) and Death Comes to Cambers (1935).
Thanks for the review. :) Of all the novels by Punshon you've read, which would you regard as the top three titles?
ReplyDeleteI'm not sure if the four books I've read would make for a good, representive top three of Punshon's work, but I would probably place Information Received first. I guess I would place Comes a Stranger second, which are closely followed by Crossword Mystery and Death Comes to Cambers.
DeleteAgain, I've hardly read enough Punshon to make such a list.
I just finished reading Comes a Stranger (I'll review on my site in a couple of weeks), but I think you hit most of the main points. I too have some quibbles (though mine, I think, were triggered more by that body in the library - but then, John Dickson Carr used a similar solution in one of his best mysteries and I didn't like it much there either). Overall, I think it is a great bibliomystery.
ReplyDeleteAgreed. I'm not an expert in the niché that's bibliomysteries, but I would rank this one among the best I have encountered thus far. In spite of some quibbles.
Delete