Georgiana
Ann Randolph is best remembered by her penname, "Craig
Rice," which she adopted in the late 1930s when creating a
triumvirate of hard-drinking, morally ambiguous, but comical,
detective-characters as memorable as Erle
Stanley Gardner's Perry Mason and Rex
Stout's Archie Goodwin – earning her the title of Queen of the
Screwball Mystery. An honorary title nobody to date has disputed and
with good reason.
Rice
was one of those rare mystery novelists who could write genuinely
funny detective stories and her second effort, The Corpse Steps
Out (1940), is arguably her best screwball mystery.
The
Corpse Steps Out takes place one and a half year after 8
Faces at 3 (1939) and John J. Malone, Jake Justus and Helene
Brand have gone their separate ways. However, they have a knack for
attracting copious amount of trouble and this destined them to meet
again, which happens when a client of Justus becomes involved in a
blackmail plot with multiple murders and bodies being lugged around
the city of Chicago – which makes this a darkly comedic, madcap
chase story in the spirit of Carter Dickson's The
Punch and Judy Murders (1936) and Norbert Davis' The
Mouse in the Mountain (1943). All of this running around
begins with the lead star of the Nelle Brown Revue finding the body
of the man who tried to blackmail her with a stack of embarrassing
love letters.
Jake
Justus appeared in 8 Faces at 3 as a newspaper reporter, but
has since gone into business for himself as a press agent and
manager. When the reader meets him again he wonders why, with untold
billions of people in the world, "everything had to pick him to
happen to." Nelle Brown is a client of Justus and he sees it as
his duty to keep her out of trouble. Even if it turns out she shot
her ex-sweetie to pieces.
There
are, however, complication and they crop up at an ever-increasing
pace: one of these complications concerns the removal of the body
from the kitchen of the crime-scene and the person responsible left a
note for the landlady – asking her to sent the belongings to
Honolulu, Hawaii. So that took care of one problem, but the love
letters are still out there and these letters pose a greater threat
for Brown's radio career than a potential murder rap.
According
to Justus, radio reaches every household in America and "you've
to keep it clean," because their sponsor would cancel the
contract in "a minute if this thing broke the wrong way."
As
you would expect by this point in the story, a second blackmailer
rears his head and wants Brown to sign a personal-management
contract, which means that he collects all of her income and pays her
a weekly salary. A nice, legal way to apply an inescapable vise-grip
on a blackmail victim, but this is not the only thumb-screw this
second blackmailer tries to apply on the radio star. Brown is forced
to perform in a secret audition for a prospective buyer of her revue,
an out-of-town soap manufacturer, but at the end of the show they
discover his body in the private room where he was listening to the
show – slumped in a chair with a bullet in his head. So they did
the only sensible thing you can do in such a situation. No, no, no.
They did not phone the police. That would be silly. They dragged the
body out of the studio, drove it to Lincoln Park and dumped the body
on a bench. But the various blackmail schemes and rising bodycount is
not the only source of comedy in this story.
After
Justus is reunited with Helene Brand, a famous beauty, socialite and
heiress, they decide to get married, but getting to knot tied is
easier said than done and every time they determined to go to Crown
Point to get married a monkey wrench, or two, is thrown into the work
– such as getting chased by a squad car full of police officers
with a body in the backseat. She even has to go into hiding until
Malone can get an arson charge off her neck. Not to mention a case of
body snatching, obstruction of justice, falsifying evidence and
resisting arrest.
Well,
you get the idea. The Corpse Steps Out is a fast-paced,
rip-roaringly funny detective story, but this does not mean that all
of the outrageous plot develops are played merely for laughs. There's
method to Rice's madness.
There
are three, convincingly motivated, shooting deaths in the story and
the second murder, one committed in the radio studio, comes with a
nifty, unexpected twist in the tail and this makes the plot rewarding
as well as funny. But even the more serious aspects of the story are
not devoid of humor. Rice mercilessly pokes fun at the type of 1920s
detective novel John
Dickson Carr criticized in his famous essay, "The Grandest Game
in the World," in which the author makes the scene of the crime
resemble a bus terminal at rush-hour as characters wander in and out
of the room – leaving behind cuff links, bus tickets, handkerchiefs
and cigarette ends. Justus observed at one point in the story that
the first murder "seems to have been one of the major social
events of the year," because "everybody was there."
Everybody was walking in and out of the apartment as the victim was
bleeding out on the kitchen floor.
My
only complaint is that my favorite shady lawyer-detective, the
incomparable John J. Malone, only has a very small role in the book.
Malone
is basically just there to provide a solution when the time comes to
wrap up the show, which is why some editions bill The Corpse Steps
Out as "A Jake Justus Mystery." However, this does nothing
diminish the sheer joy and clever aspects of the story. I would
actually recommend readers who are new to Rice to begin with The
Corpse Steps Out instead of 8 Faces at 3, because it gives
you a good idea what Rice was capable of doing when she was in
top-form.
Anyway,
in my case, I'm glad that for once I saved one of the better entries
in a series for last, which is not something that happens very often.
There are, however, two posthumously, ghostwritten novels, The
Picked Poodles (1960) and But the Doctor Died (1968), but
they're considered to be piss-poor in quality and the latter was
reputedly written as an attempt to cash in on the spy craze –
except that this last "official" title in the series is
completely devoid of Rice's trademark sense of humor.
So
this only leaves me with a collection of short stories (The Name
is Malone, 1960) and the three mystery novels she wrote as "Michael Venning," but those are stories I'll get to another
time.
BUT THE DOCTOR DIED was, I believe, written by Rice. It was found among her papers and appears to be a first draft. THE PICKLED POODLES was written by Larry M. Harris (Lawrence Janifer) and published under his name, therefore not really ghost-written. Harris, by the way, wrote three science fiction books (with Randall Garrett under the joint pseudonym 'Mark Phillips") about Kevin Malone, who, the books hinted, was a descendant of John J. Malone. These three books -- BRAIN TWISTER, THE IMPOSSIBLES, and SUPERMIND -- are all great fun.
ReplyDeleteI always understood that the book was likely ghosted, because the personalities of Malone, Jake and Helene were unrecognizable and the writing lacked Rice's madcap humor. I suppose the book could have been written around a plot outline or rough draft, but I gathered from various that the finished novel was written by an unknown ghostwriter.
DeleteThanks for the head ups on the Kevin Malone books. Are they SF mysteries?
The three Kenneth J. Malone novels are about an FBI agent. They are science fiction mysteries but involve criminals and other parties with mental powers like teleportation and telepathy. They are written in a comic style. They are fun reading, but don't expect any Golden Age plot complexities. They were originally published in the late 1950s and early 1960s in Astounding Stories/Analog.
ReplyDeleteThank you for letting me know. I probably won't get around to them anytime soon, but will keep them in mind on account of the John J. Malone connection.
DeleteThanks for the review, which put Craig Rice back on my radar. To date, I’ve only recently read “The Wrong Murder”, and intend to leave “Home Sweet Homicide” to the last. Would you say “Corpse Steps Out” is even better?
ReplyDeleteBetter than Home Sweet Homicide? I don't think so, but there are probably people who would disagree with that.
Delete