In 2022, I compiled a wishlist, "Curiosity is Killing the Cat: Detective Novels That Need to Be Reprinted," comprising of some extremely obscure, practically forgotten and out-of-print novels and writers – all sorely in need of fresh printing-ink. I admit the list was mostly put together with wishful thinking as some of the entries looked pretty hopeless at the time. Some of those apparently hopeless items have since returned to print like the complete works of James Ronald, but I was just as surprised to see two other names on that list return to print. They were both reprinted by Serling Lake as part of their "Impossible Crime Classics" series.
Back in February, Serling Lake published the first new edition of W.A. Mackenzie's Flower O' the Peach (1916) in 110 years and last year they reprinted Charles Chadwick's The Moving House of Foscaldo (1925/26). A once exceedingly rare mystery novel praised by Robert Adey as "an undeservedly obscure novel" of "adventure rather than a detective novel," but "very well written." I ended up agreeing after finishing the book and the impossible crime element is far above of the average locked room mystery from the early to mid-1920s. A period when secret passages, venomous animals and dubious twins were still lurking about. So hoped they would not overlook Chadwick's other detective novel of equal obscurity, The Cactus (1925), but that hope appeared to be dashed earlier in the year.After the February reprint of Mackenzie's Flower O' the Peach, Serling Lake stopped publishing and updating their website. Normally, it doesn't bode well when one of these small, print-on-demand publishers suddenly go silent. In June, or thereabout, they updated the covers of their previous edition and published a new reprint, William Allison's A Secret of the Sea (1920), before going quiet again – until they dropped a reprint of Chadwick's The Cactus in September. So they're still around, but (as of this writing) on an irregular publishing schedule.
The Cactus resurrects Chadwick's Bob Ellis, a young lawyer, who appeared in series of short stories and at least one novella published (as by "Daniel Steele") in the early 1910s in The Popular Magazine. I've no idea why the short stories were published under a pseudonym and the novel under his own name, but doubt anyone at the time connected Chadwick's The Cactus with the pre-WWI short stories by Steele. My only guess is Chadwick simply wanted to give his detective the sendoff that eluded him in The Popular Magazine.
The prologue introduces Bob Ellis as a former lawyer-detective who has comfortably settled down as an attorney and counselor-at-law ("no more of this crime-chasing, man-hunting stuff in my young life"), but witnessing a strange scene through a window of a drug store proves a prelude to murder. Some time later, Ellis is at a dinner party with the principle players of the story. There's the host, Mrs. Augusta Halberd, her sister Miss Cecilia Wayne and a niece, Miss Flores Wayne, along with several notable and foreign guests. The Hon. Joaquin Chavez, Mexican consul in New York, Mrs. Chavez and the consul's secretary, Señor Jesús Verassas. This party is rounded out by the Assistant D.A. Francis Warner and Bob Ellis. So the after dinner conversation turns to Warner's cases, but, beside an old poisoning case, the only remarkable thing that recently happened was a pair of suicides ("one attempted, one successful"). Warner tells them about the two cases.
Firstly, the attempted suicide of an escaped convict, Red Leary, who was found in a Greenwich Village backyard "loaded to the muzzle with some kind of deadly poison" and "holding in his hand a wooden slat about eight feet long," but fortunately recovered – only statement he gave was that he tried to end it all. Secondly, the successful suicide curiously enough happened only a stone throw's from the first. Some poor fellow stabbed himself with a clasp-knife in tenement room whose only window overlooked the yard where Red Leary was found. The door was locked, window fastened and the key found inside the room, but this immediately leads to a discussion the man could have been murdered. They even come up with a simple method to make it appear the room was locked from the inside ("...perhaps there is a crack under the door..."). Warner immediately checks up on this suggestion and is immediately disproved as the door was both locked and bolted. What's more, it turns out the victim was stabbed twice and redressed. So it was murder. When they learn the victim's identity, Flores Wayne breaks down and collapses.
This scene of the dinner guests discussing the two suicides, raising the possibility of murder and suggesting a false-solution to the problem of the locked door shows Chadwick was in certain ways years ahead of his contemporaries. The first-half of The Cactus much more resembles a formal detective novel of the time than The Moving House of Foscaldo with Ellis trying to get answers out of Flores and new revelations, twists and turns about the locked room murder coming to light. One of them being a mysterious man who turned up at the crime, introducing himself as Domingo Roderiguez, who then disappears heading towards the border.So the second-half has Ellis and Flores following the trail leading from New York to Texas and finally Mexico to go on a treasure hunt for a hidden inheritance involving an abandoned mine and coded messages. The second-half of The Cactus becomes more a tale of adventure and romance, but ends with Ellis confronting the killer and explaining their various crimes.
The explanation of what happened in that locked, bolted tenement bedroom and in the garden below has two fascinating features: the method for poisoning Red Leary and how the killer locked the bedroom. They don't appear especially original as most readers have probably come across them before, until you realize The Cactus was published in 1925. I wrecked my brain and drew a complete blank on examples predating Chadwick's The Cactus. That becomes historically significant, if Chadwick was the first to employ that particular locked room-trick. A locked room-trick that has not exactly been done to death, but most impossible crime fanatics have come across (variations of) it more than once. It would be amazing accomplishment if that trick originated with Chadwick. From what I gathered, Chadwick's two mysteries were well received and read at the time. Even his obituary mentions them. It's entirely possible Chadwick provided this handy way to create a locked room murder.
So while the passage of time blunted the stronger points of The Cactus, I closed the book with the same feeling as The Moving House of Foscaldo. You would expect sterner, tougher stuff from a former college athlete who competed in the hammer-throw event at the 1904 Olympics, but Chadwick obviously took his cue from the early French mystery writers Gaston Leroux, Maurice Leblanc and probably Émile Gaboriau. That means they're not always as strong on detection or clueing as you might wish/demand, but very rich in imagination, original ideas and remain remarkable readable and fresh a century on. What a shame Chadwick never returned to the detective story after 1926. Just imagine what imaginative and creative locked room novels and short stories he could have written in the 1930s and '40s. So... I can definitely recommend Chadwick's The Cactus and The Moving House of Foscaldo as early, unjustly forgotten Golden Age novels mixing murder and mystery with adventure and romance.
Note for the curious: Serling Lake deserves a nod for shining a new light over the locked room mystery of the pre-1930s era that has been somewhat overlooked and dismissed over the decades – something I have been guilty of myself. At least not before 1927, 1928. These reprints of not only Chadwick and Mackenzie, but also Robert Orr Chipperfield's surprisingly good Above Suspicion (1922/23) renewed my interest in these early impossible crime novels. So, if anyone from Serling Lake happens to stumble across this review, I've a few suggestions picked from the public domain. Jacques Aanrooy's Off the Track (1895), Fred M. White's Who Killed James Trent? (1901), Edward Gellibrand's The End of a Cigarette (1924), Chadwick's short stories and the 1916 translation of Gaston Leroux's L'homme qui revient de loin (The Man Who Came Back from the Dead, 1912). Maybe, if they're not too late to qualify, Christopher Booth's Deceiver's Door (1929) and Morrison Dupree's A Tap on the Shoulder (1929).


No comments:
Post a Comment