"One sees great things from the valley; only small things from the peak."- Father Brown (G.K. Chesterton's "The Hammer of God," from The Innocence of Father Brown, 1911)
Martin Edwards
is a British crime writer and author of an upcoming book, The Golden Age of Murder (2015), discussing the London Detection Club and examining "the
mystery of the writers who invented the modern detective story."
Do You Write Under Your Own Name is Edwards' personal blog, represented here on the
blog-roll of Insightful Informants, and two interesting posts appeared on there
recently – concerning a resurgent interest in the Golden Age of Detective
Fiction.
The first post,
"And the latest runaway bestseller is," considers the unexpected success
harvest by the British Library Crime Classics with the republication of Mystery
in White: A Christmas Crime Story (1937) by J.J. Farjeon. We'll leave it to
the scholars to debate who was more obscure, the book or its author, but the
reprint of this long-forgotten mystery novel sold over 60.000 copies! The
second post, "Golden Age reflections," asks the opinion of the
blog-readers of why a rival of the classic crime novel is happening now.
Well, I believe
it's been happening, slowly but surely, for a while now and began when the
internet offered a free and open market place to small, independent publishing
houses. Rue Morgue Press, House of Stratus and Crippen & Landru began in
the early 2000s with reintroducing then forgotten mystery writers such as Glyn Carr, Anthony Berkeley, Torrey Chanslor, Craig Rice, Joseph Commings, Kelley Roos and Freeman Wills Crofts. It steadily expanded the available material to
readers of Golden Age fiction beyond the shelves of secondhand bookshops and
rummage stores.
A notable
success story of these reprints is Gladys Mitchell, whose output was largely
forgotten and next to impossible to find. That was until the Rue Morgue Press
began reprinting some of her work, such as Death at the Opera (1934) and
When Last I Died (1941), while Crippen & Landru collected all of
Mitchell's short stories under the title Sleuth's Alchemy: Cases of Mrs. Bradley and Others (2005). Minnow Press reproduced a handful of expensive,
hardcover edition of some of the harder to find titles in the Mrs. Bradley
series. That was a decade ago and since then multiple publishers, big and
small, republished nearly every mystery novel the prolific Mitchell wrote in
her lifetime – and most of them were expensive collector items only a decade
ago!
60.000 copies sold! The ride never ends. |
The secondhand
book hawkers of the internet market place also did their part in putting little
known, long out-of-print detective stories back in the hands of readers, which
made collecting vintage mysteries look really easy. However, I'll grudgingly
admit that the growing popularity of e-readers and a growing catalogue of
public-domain titles may've drawn a serious crowd of new readers to our genre.
The names in the public domain are monuments of the transitional period between
Sherlock Holmes with his Rivals and the Golden Age: Sir Arthur Conan Doyle
(Sherlock Holmes), G.K. Chesterton (Father Brown), Maurice Leblanc (Arsène
Lupin), Jacques Futrelle (The Thinking Machine) and R. Austin Freeman (Dr. John
Thorndyke). To name just a few. And their books are free or offered in bundles
for pennies on the dollars.
Now juxtapose
all of that to the stale, rigidly state of the contemporary crime novels
topping the "Crime Bestseller Lists" for the past 20-30 years. The crime novel
with cover art besieging you to consider it proper literature, exploring the
criminal nature of mankind in a series of mini-biographies of the characters,
guaranteeing a book bound with more substance than its plot. What about the
character-driven series of police procedurals with a troubled cop or the
literary thrillers in the hardboiled vein with a jaded protagonist. It's the
same old, same old, come-and go realism critics have been raving about for
decades and chugging awards at for "Transcending the Genre," character
exploration and prose that's probably "stone-cold" or "ultra-modern."
A personal favorite reprinted by RMP |
I believe the
entrenchment of the contemporary crime novel, together with its tropes
and clichés, while pretending to be the only game in town, is what kept drawing
a bigger audience of readers to the detective stories of yore – offering even a
wider variety of crime stories than its modern counterpart. Whodunits,
howdunits, locked room and impossible crime stories, thrillers of all stripes,
rogue stories, forensic mysteries, suspense, gothic romances, socially aware
detectives, comedy of manners, spy intrigues, "Had-I-But-Known," historical mysteries, parodies and pastiches, hardboiled, softboiled, adventure-hybrids,
SciFi-hybrids, early police procedurals, juvenile mysteries, etc. I think the abundance of short stories
produced during the Golden years are being appreciated all over again by modern
readers, because you can easily read one or two stories on the train or bus to
kill the time.
From a consumer's
perspective, it's completely understandable why these stories have become
interesting again. They offer the reader a genuine choice and a majority can be
downloaded with a swipe of a finger on your e-reader, of which a significant
portion is in the public domain – completely free-of-charge. How can those
stale, dime-a-dozen "Literary Thrillers" and "Crime Novels" compete with that?
Personally, I
hope this expanding interest in the classics is a response to the postmodern
deconstructivism, which is at the root of the contemporary crime movement,
because I believe we're leaving that period behind us.
What's left to deconstruct? Even the major prizes are given out to writers only
marginally associated with the genre. So why would readers put up with the same themes being crammed down theirs throats how the world can be a dark, violent
and unfair place swamped in corruption and deceit. That message has been duly
noted over the past 15 years.