4/4/24

Green for Danger (1944) by Christianna Brand

Green for Danger (1944) is Christianna Brand's second novel about her series-detective, Inspector Cockrill, which is not only regarded as her crowning achievement as a mystery novelist, but considered to be one of the best, Golden Age whodunits ever written – comparable only to the best from John Dickson Carr and Agatha Christie. Last year, I listed Green for Danger in the "Top 10 Fascinating World War II Detective Novels" and revisited Suddenly at His Residence (1946). A somewhat conventional country house mystery, but brilliant and daringly plotted. And infinitely better than I remembered from my first read. But, as pointed out in the comments, Suddenly at His Residence is not even Brand's third, fourth or even fifth best detective novel. To quote James Scott Byrnside, "she was the best." So wanted to take another look at Brand's masterpiece to see if stands up. It did!

The backdrop of Green for Danger is Heron's Park, a former children's sanitarium "hurriedly scrambled into shape as a military hospital," situated three miles out of Heronsford in Kent. Brand introduced the primary characters in the first chapter through Joseph Higgins, a postman, who pushes his old, battered bicycle up hill to deliver seven letters at the hospital. Seven letters addressed to the seven principle players.

Firstly, there are the two surgeons, Gervase Eden of Harley Street fame and the long-time Heronsford physician Major Moon, backed by Sister Marion Bates and the local anesthetist, Dr. Barnes. Rounding out this little, tightly-knit group are three VADs (Voluntary Aid Detachments), Frederica Linley, Esther Sanson and Jane Woods. A varied group of people, all with their own backstories, brought together at Heron's Park under wartime conditions and Brand ends the first chapter with the following line, "he could not know that, just a year later, one of the writers would die, self-confessed a murderer" – drawing a tightly "closed circle" before the murder has taken place. Another thing Higgins could not have imagined is that he would be the first victim of this murderer.

A year later, Heronsford suffers a heavy, nighttime air-raid, "A.R.P. centre has been hit, among other places, and there are a lot of casualties," which begins to fill up the hospital beds ("...now it’s time for work!"). Joseph Higgins is brought in with a fractured femur and scheduled for surgery the following morning. Higgins spends a long, restless night muttering in his bed ("where have I heard that voice?") before being brought to the operating theater. They ensure Higgins that the procedure is not dangerous, "hardly an operation at all," but something did go wrong. And the patient dies on the operating table. There's no apparent reason why he died before they even made an incision, "they pip off for no rhyme or reason and you never know exactly why," but the authorities have to be notified. Detective Inspector Cockrill arrives at Heron's Park two days later under the assumption he's handling "just another anæsthetic death” (“you doctors slay 'em off in their thousands"). However, the case doesn't end with that single fatal incident in the operating theater.

If Death of Jezebel (1948) is Brand trying her hands at a Carr-style locked room mystery, Green for Danger is her take on Christie's conversational-style whodunits like Murder on the Orient Express (1934).

Green for Danger takes the "mainly conversation" approach as it tells its story, fleshes out the characters and setting the scenes mostly through dialogue. So no wonder the 1947 movie adaptation, starring Alastair Sim, is commonly regarded as one of the best adaptations of a Golden Age mystery novel as the book itself almost reads like a movie script. Not even the alterations to the original story could diminish the brilliance of the novel with perhaps the biggest difference between the two is that the movie has a slightly more light-hearted, comedic tone. What should not be overlooked about the original novel is why Green for Danger is considered to be the best of the British World War II mysteries. The descriptions of its wartime surroundings act as punctuations in the narrative flow with the incessant "droning of aero-planes overhead," the hospital shaking with "the thundering of the guns in the neighbouring fields" or "now and again with the sickening thud of a bomb" – occasional glimpses of the patients who fill the hospital beds after every air-raid. From bandaged people lying in their beds or wandering around the place to the hospital comedians cracking jokes every time a bomb falls ("they've 'eard about the pudding we 'ad today, nurse, and they're trying to kill the cook").

So, all of that being said, Brand did dabble in a little bit of physical clueing in such an original and brilliant way, it deserves to be highlighted. This inspired piece of physical clueing comes in the form of a murdered nurse, "laid out ceremonially on the operating table, rigged up elaborately in a surgical gown and mask and gloves, with huge white rubber boots on her feet," who had been brutally stabbed to death. A macabre detail is that one of the stab wounds was delivered after the victim was already dead. It's always tricky to do additional murders without making them come across as mere page padding, but Green for Danger demonstrates how to make a second murder count and milk it for all it's worth. A lesson Byrnside, a devout Brandian, took to heart when he started writing his own detective novels (e.g. The Opening Night Murders, 2019).

When cobbling together "The Hit List: Top 10 Fascinating World War II Detective Novels," I feared Green for Danger was perhaps too well-known for the list and considered replacing it. I'm glad I decided to keep it on the list, because Green for Danger lives up to its reputation as the best and most famous of all British WWII mystery novels. And because of how it exploited it's wartime setting, it becomes so much more than just another, very well-done whodunit from one of the Golden Age greats. Green for Danger is simply one of the dozen, or so, best detective novels from Golden Age and can't heap more praise on it.

A Tip for the Curious: Green for Danger is Brand's best-known novel and generally accepted as her masterpiece, but there are some contrarians out there claiming London Particular (1952) is her finest piece of detective fiction. British Library is going to publish a long overdue reprint of London Particular later this month. So you can soon judge for yourself.

12 comments:

  1. I'm always a little surprised that Green for Danger is considered the definitive Brand over Death of Jezebel, which I like a lot more. Green for Danger's good (especially compared to Suddenly at Her Residence, which I don't care for at all), but the section from the 2nd murder to the denouement always dragged a bit for me. Death of Jezebel has a bit of the same problem, but the dizzying amount of fake solutions shown in the 2nd half of that book give it something more. I may just be weird though, cuz Tour de Force is my 2nd favorite Brand, and that seems to be one of the least liked ones in general.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I'm hugely relieved to FINALLY learn there's someone else not madly in love with GReen for Danger. I dragged myself to the end and by the time I did the biggest mystery for me was "why do so many rave about this one?" You singled out the last half upt the dénouement, and it's that climax which was my biggest issue. I simply cannot grok how "we'll confirm whodunnit by letting them try again" AND they nearly get away with it. is considered masterly detective work No deduction, no froensic examination of clues justr " I have a hunch it's X, let's see if repeating the crime proves my hunch right"

      Delete
    2. You're not the only one who loves Death of Jezebel, but have to reread it to see where it, exactly, stands. Don't forget Death of Jezebel was until recently a very scarce, hard-to-get title and simply never got to fight Green for Danger over “the definitive Brand” title. Going by the comments on here, I suspect that's about to change.

      Tour de Force the least liked Brand in general? That's not my impression. When I read it, it didn't register as a classic masterpiece, but ever since, everyone seems to think it's one of Brand's greatest triumphs.

      Delete
  2. As ever , a fascinating look at a major crime novel. I am a Brand fan ,but did find the last part did drag a little. I actually thought the film dealt with this problem more effectively ;if pushed ,I would pick the film over the book, but either way , two brilliant pieces of mis direction !

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I'm not sure if I would pick the movie over the book, but it certainly is one of the best adaptations of a Golden Age detective story.

      Delete
  3. I am a new Brand fan. Green for Danger is good, but as a locked room fan, Death of Jezebel is my favorite. Really glad that BLCC decided to reprint her works.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. And they're not done yet. London Particular is coming out this month and Tour de Force later this year.

      Delete
  4. I own this (somewhere) but never wanted to read it before Suddenly at His Residence which I haven't found at the library. I did not know there was a film!

    ReplyDelete
  5. With the misdirection alone, so expert even Agatha Christie probably envied it, Green for Danger deserves a top spot among the Golden Age of Detection. Brand in general is wonderful, her worst novel I've read is Suddenly at His Residence, and I'd still probably read that over the best of Ngaio Marsh. But then, I don't need to remind anyone I'm a fan of Brand!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Brand was so good, the only real argument we're still having is which novel is her definitive masterpiece. Green for Danger, Death of Jezebel or perhaps Tour de Force or London Particular?

      I rate Suddenly at His Residence a lot higher than most, because on its own it's a first-rate detective novel, but calling it Brand's worst novel is a compliment in her case. Suddenly at His Residence is what you produce on an off day? There more than one of Brand's contemporaries who wished they had "rainy days" like that. Enough fanboying for one day. :D

      Delete
  6. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete