"But when the third... gets killed, and all three of them in the same territory, I begin to get suspicious."- Capt. Daniel von Flanagan (Craig Rice's The Fourth Postman, 1951)
Jakob van Schevichaven (1866-1935) is
considered here to be the first professional Dutch mystery writer, under the
single-name pseudonym "Ivans," who paved the way for later popular writers such
as "Havank" and A.C. Baantjer.
I've read and heard about the Fathers of
Dutch Crime Fiction, Ivans and Havank, but never got around to reading any of
their detective stories, because there's mainly biographical information on the
web – while the available plot summaries tend to be vague, unappealing or
spoiler ridden. So I never gave them to good old college try. Well, recently, I
found a copy of De bosgeest (The Forest Spirit, 1926) on my
shelves and thought: why not. It has to happen sometime.
 |
| Book has a ton of these illustrations! |
Ivans' series characters are a well know,
celebrated English detective, named Geoffrey "G.G." Gill, and a Dutch lawyer,
Willem Hendriks, who has been chronicling his cases since De man uit
Frankrijk (The Man from France, 1917). Gill and Hendriks were
obviously cast from the same mold as Sherlock Holmes and Dr. John Watson, but,
interestingly, Hendriks was presented as a more developed, individual character
while G.G. acted more as one of the stereotypical, lower-ranking Rivals of Sherlock Holmes, i.e. Martin Hewitt.
The Forest Spirit was originally published in 1926, but Hendriks informs the reader
the story took place several years before The Great War (i.e. First World War)
and began with a telegram from G.G. announcing his arrival the next day. G.G.
invites Hendriks, alongside with his family (wife and daughter), on a trip to the Eifel (Germany)
where they soak up the landscape of hill-and low mountain tops, ruins of
medieval strongholds, circle-shaped lakes (maar) and lots of green –
even the rude, inhospitable locals can't dampen the mood. The problems begin
when a mistake, made at the hotel they booked, forced them to take refuge in a familiepension
(hostel). Hendriks wakes up in the middle of the night to see a dark form with
yellow/green eyes peering at him through the open bedroom window, but,
naturally, there was nothing to be found upon investigation.
I think there was something positively tantalizing
about a ghostly apparition in an early 1900s mountain hostel in Germany,
followed by the striking of matches and flickering, dying lights of fire, as a
household of guests awakes in utter confusion. It was a brief, but nice, scene,
I thought! Moving on...
 |
| Old-fashioned spelling of De Bosgeest |
The next day, during one of their daily
hikes, G.G. and Hendriks, see a frightened road worker running and screaming "murder"
and "bosgeest," which leads them to the body of a forest ranger and he
wasn't the first one to be murdered in the region. Previously, three forest
rangers have been murdered, back of their heads caved in, but the police have
never been able to find any trace of the murderer. In the last case, the
victim was found by following his footsteps, it had rained just before, but they
were also the only footprints discovered on the scene – fanning the flames of
superstition. Amazingly, the impossible situation of the footprints is
mentioned only once and the problem explained itself in the end, which became
a slight disappointment as I read on. No theorizing? False solutions? Boo!
Seasoned mystery readers familiar with
the early classics will probably experience an "aha" moment at this point, but,
first, I have to credit Ivans here for not blatantly copying Edgar Allan Poe or
Sir Arthur Conan Doyle. It was also a good idea to split the interest for the
only real suspect in the game in two camps: the official police, who think he's
guilty, while G.G. is convinced he's afraid of the spirit. I was never quite
sure if I was on the right track, even though I picked up on an obscure clue, which
is what I liked. What I don't like, however, is that I still don't know if I
like The Forest Spirit. Ivans went full "Weird Menace" with the
solution, and I grunted when it was confirmed, but the explanation is unsettlingly
convincing and the motive has a lot to do with it. That, and the villain of the
story. Mary Gregor from Anthony Wynne's The Silver Scale Mystery (1931)
and Mr. Ratchett from Agatha Christie's The Murder on the Orient Express
(1935) were saints compared to this character!
So, yeah, I'm divided on The Forest
Spirit, which began as a mysterious travelogue set in Caspar David Friedrich
Der Wanderer über dem Nebelmeer (Wanderer Above the Mist),
merging into Holmesian-era detective story and ending on an unsettling weird
note... but I can't get pass the how of the murders. I don't think I like it, but
than again, I'm probably too traditional minded for the alternative crime novel.
That is John's department.
I read "De man uit Frankrijk" and "Het spook van Vöröshegy" (the first and second book in the GG series) this week by the way and am kinda divided on them. They are reasonably amusing reads, I will admit that, but the (impossible) crimes are dissappointing as they're fairly obviously possible and the plot twists can be quite overdramatic and implausible.
ReplyDeleteLove the cover art though!
Interesting you feel the same way. De Bosgeest was an amusing read, yes, but I'm afraid Ivans is one of those writers who's an acquired taste. Like Harry Stephen Keeler.
DeleteLove the cover art as well and wonder now if Het Brocken Spook has an impossible situation. I might have to tackle that one sooner than I thought.